Toasted - Newburgh

American, Vegan, Sandwiches
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Toasted.

Toasted

Toasted
4.4 / 5 (94 reviews)

Description

Toasted is a hidden gem on Liberty Street that captivates with its eclectic ambiance and vibrant atmosphere. Although the food has garnered mixed reviews—ranging from the delicious fried oyster mushroom sandwich to disappointing hamburgers—the overall dining experience is enhanced by the engaging live music and friendly staff. The owner, Sam, is known for his exceptional cocktails and attentive service. Guests can enjoy both indoor and outdoor seating while savoring a unique menu and local spirits. With its funky interior and lively vibe, Toasted promises a memorable experience, making it a recommended stop for anyone visiting Newburgh.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: User

Reservation request for Toasted

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 94 reviews
toadbear
17.02.2024

The cocktails are excellent and the beer selection is always changing, making for a great experience. Some of the best performances I have seen in Newburgh have been at this restaurant. The artists are top-notch and the DJs really know how to keep the energy up in the room. Sam, who I think is the owner or manager, always makes me fantastic cocktails and remembers my preferences, impressing me every time. He definitely deserves his tips.

sahr-bundor
17.02.2024

Great bar with a mix of music and events from week to week. Interior is well decorated and staff is friendly and helpful. Great spot off from the Newburgh waterfront that has a local feel but very modern trendy atmosphere.

jonathan-falcon
17.02.2024

Great bar that always has dope events. Definitely check it out.

Love the atmosphere here. Experienced, knowledgeable bartenders and cooks. They put all their love into the drinks and food! Every time I’ve dined here, it’s been nothing but the best time. The owner Sam is lovely. Definitely created a greatestablishment that the community needed. Highly recommended!

jeffrey-jeff-2
17.02.2024

Good vibes and chilled atmosphere.

FAQ

The restaurant offers complimentary WLAN for its guests.

The diner is accessible and can therefore also be used with a wheelchair or physical disabilities.

The restaurant accepts the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.