Images
ContributeNo images to show
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Brooks Keebler likes about Cosimo's Pizza:
I had a great meal at this restaurant. The food was excellent, I would rate it 10/10. The service was outstanding as well. I will definitely be coming back here every time I eat out. I didn't have any issues with the waitstaff. They seemed to know exactly what I wanted even though I had never been there before. I can't understand why some people have left negative reviews, this place is definitely a hidden gem in the... View all feedback.
What Madeleine Gonzalez doesn't like about Cosimo's Pizza:
I did not enjoy the baked ziti. It did not taste homemade and the pasta seemed stale, as if it had been sitting out all day. It seemed like they quickly tossed the sauce on and reheated it in the microwave. I was very disappointed. This was my first time dining here and it may be my last. I think I'll just stick to ordering pizza next time. It's best to stick to the basics. View all feedback.
Food was Good.Nice Friendly Staff.Quick Service.It Was 2 yrs.ago i was there
My pizza had just enough vegetables and spices for my taste and the temperature was just right.
When they live in America and work learning English! somehow you couldn't order because girls didn't speak English.
I am a regular customer. the steak sizzler is the best. my wife loves the cloak pocket. the only critique is to bring the lobster baguette back.
Eat here. eating is 10/10 good. and service is absolutely amazing. I'll tap every time, I'll eat there. no problems with waitress. If you've eaten almost the year there, they'll find out what I wanted is out there. I have no evidence of why this place has some bad reviews. this is only the best part of the small newburgh mall sad.
Full Menu
Bread
This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients
More information
QR-code link to the menu
