Shellhammer's - Feedback

Wine, American, Mexican

Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.2 out of 5
Impressive | 7433 reviews

Reviews from various websites

Menu

Last update : 24.04.2023

5.0 ★ from 11 reviews

We were the first customers last Friday night, and I must say, Athena was fantastic! The food was great, but the service exceeded our expectations. We will definitely return, especially if we have attentive servers like Athena and Noel. This place came highly recommended by others, and it certainly lived up to the praise.

I had a lovely meal at this restaurant, and the atmosphere was fantastic, though it was quite filled with older patrons. I ordered the meat dish, which was quite tasty. While it didn't quite measure up to my mom's cooking, it was still pretty good!

My burger was fantastic! The fries could have used a bit more seasoning, but our waiter provided some extra. It had been over a decade since I last visited, and I’m really glad I came back. My son felt his French dip was a bit lacking, but my Shemp Burger was excellent.

Fantastic. The dishes and drinks were delicious. We went to Burgernacht and the burgers were so delicious I forgot to make a picture of them. We'll be back soon.

Shellhammers has some of the tastiest food choices for a bar! I love it. The happy hour prices are great the food tastes good and not like bar food. The bartender, Josh is just 1 of the standout staff members who has always shown great customer care, remembered our names and our favorite drink/food choices even if we hadn 't been there in 6 months ? One time while a classmate and I decided to meet their and catch up. Towards the end of our meal, a gentleman put $20 on our table (I suppose to help with our bill) and all he said was have a nice day I asked Josh who he was and he said a very nice regular That act of kindness has stuck with me and I will pay it forward ???

Nestled in a welcoming atmosphere, this restaurant stands out for its exceptional service and delectable fare. Diners rave about the delicious burgers, impressive meat dishes, and standout items like the Shemp Burger, all served with a side of attentive care from staff members, including memorable bartenders like Josh. Patrons appreciate the inviting ambiance, making it a favorite for social gatherings or casual meals. With reasonable happy hour prices and a community spirit highlighted by acts of kindness among regulars, this eatery not only satisfies hunger but fosters a sense of belonging, ensuring patrons eagerly plan their return visits.

Int Restaurants

Last update : 29.08.2023

4.4 ★ from 1657 reviews
marianne-589
29.08.2023

I've gone there with my friends over the years, and have always been happy to go back. The food is good and the staff is warm friendly to the customer's, and it's clean and inviting bar atmosphere.

cammy-20
29.08.2023

Food was to die for. Absolutely loved it. Will be going again

marian-468
29.08.2023

Love Wednesday night burgers! Delicious Shemp burger! Great place to gather with friends!

refika
29.08.2023

This is one of my favorite places! I really wish they had a location in New Jersey, but whenever we're in the area, we always make a stop. The atmosphere is fantastic, the music is always great, the service is excellent, and the food is simply amazing! Cheers to that!

stephanie-3149
29.08.2023

Great atmosphere, great Margarita, and $6 burger were great on Wednesday's. Thursdays are $5 Margarita. The staff were very friendly and helpful. Must visit

Heyrestaurants

Last update : 30.04.2024

3.7 ★ from 4963 reviews
sandra-w-dog5
30.04.2024

The food was delicious, the service was outstanding, and the Chardonnay was fantastic. They offer great Happy Hour prices that are very affordable! The atmosphere is friendly and the ambiance is inviting. Overall, it's the best experience...

paul-s-vine488
30.04.2024

Great place to have something to eat especially the fajitas on Thursdays. Drinks and atmosphere are excellent!!

marianne-d-fox513
30.04.2024

I've gone there with my friends over the years, and have always been happy to go back. The food is good and the staff is warm friendly to the customer...

charles-b-cat6
30.04.2024

We had a graduation party of 16 . The food was good . The prices were a little high . Our waitress was OUTSTANDING ! I left her over 20 percent , and...

pat-r-vine2924
30.04.2024

I dined and had drinks at Shellhammers once and took a seat at the bar. I was immediately struck by the incredibly attractive staff—it's like I stepped into an Abercrombie and Fitch ad.

Sirved

Last update : 27.03.2025

4.1 ★ from 620 reviews
jenny-kenney-2
27.03.2025

Fantastic service. The food and drinks were delicious. We went on burger night and the burgers were so delicious I forgot to take a picture of them. We will definitely be back soon.

robert-rodewald-squi
27.03.2025

A very nice meal, the atmosphere is terrific, also full of Boomers. I had the meatloaf, and it was pretty good. Not as good as my mama's, but it was pretty good.

heather-kearney-3
27.03.2025

First time customers last Friday night. Athena was amazing! Not only was the food good, but the service was even better. We will defiantly be back- but only if we have excellent servers like Athena and Noel. Will be recommending to others.

charles-w-squirrel1-
27.03.2025

My burger was excellent. The fries could have been a little more seasoned but our waiter brought more seasoning. I hadn't been here for over a decade. I'm glad I came back. Now my son felt his French dip was a bit bland, but my Shemp Burger was great.

angie
27.03.2025

Shellhammers has some of the tastiest food choices for a bar! I love it. The happy hour prices are great the food tastes good and not like bar food. The bartender, Josh is just 1 of the standout staff members who has always shown great customer care,remembered our names and our favorite drink/food choices even if we hadn 't been there in 6 months ???? One time while aclassmate and I decided to meet their and catch up. Towards the end of our meal, a gentleman put $20 on our table (I suppose tohelp with our bill) and all he said was have a nice day I asked Josh who he was and he said a very nice regular That act ofkindness has stuck with me and I will pay it forward ????????????

Yelp
4.0 ★ from 182 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near Newark