Sliced By Harlem Pizza Co

Got three slices of pizza here through too good to go.Thick, heavy, dry cheese, sauce was too thick and not tomato-ey, very sugary marinara sauce.More importantly I got diarrhea. I'm not certain it was from here but the only other thing I ate was a cream cheese and smoked salmon bagel from a bagel place. Crucially, three friends ate bagels too and didn't get diarrhea whereas only I got pizza here. It is however possible something else caused it so I won't speak in absolutes. Nonetheless it is worth mentioning. Regardless the pizza was very poor and I do not recommend.

I don't understand the low reviews for this place; the chicken parm slice is about as good (and price-wise) as you find.

Scouting the university and stopped in for a quick bite. The place looks unassuming but we were happily surprised to find the awesome upper level seating and great service. And the pizzas were great!!!!Food: 5/5

My go to pizza slice near Columbia's campus. They'll happily add any toppings to your slice. Service is quick and you can eat upstairs where it's nice and quiet.

A little overpriced but I believe its one of the better pizza spots in the area. Pizza is a little bit too thick for my liking. If you like a more cheesy pizza with less sauce this is the place for you.