Scarr's Pizza - New York City

This place has shown me over the last year or so how consistent it is. I can go there at 12PM, 5PM or 11PM and the flavor will always be the same. They mill their own flour, and they source their own cheese. The quality of the food enhances the flavor of the slices. Whether you get a plain slice or a pepperoni of the regular or square kind, you won’t be disappointed. The dough is crunchy and light And the sauce is ALWAYS on point The cheese is not oily at all and so is the pepperoni The place is always clean, the staff is overall friendly It’s worth the wait when there’s a line and they’re fast at serving Can’t recommend this enough

Love love love love LOVE love this place SO much. It's amazing pizza and prob the best I've had in NYC to date and I've eaten a lot of it. I mention this place to anyone that's visiting the area.

The best place to get pizza in NYC. No frills; just great. Consistently great!

Scarr's is always a stop to get a stellar slice. Keep it simple with a cheese slice or get a Sicilian slice. It just might be the best one you've ever had. Plus, they put so much love into the flour they use to make their dough. And it's a standout. Their pandemic setup is simple and effective for eating a slice on the go.

No frills place but the service is better than that of a fine dining establishment. the woman who took our order around 1230pm-1pm on Saturday was incredibly patient and kind, especially given the line. we appreciate them being open during the pandemic — thank you! the pizza is just as good, the Sicilian’s crust is perfectly cooked! five stars!