Pizza By Lucille's - New York City

I ordered the meatball pizza and garlic knots. The meatballs were really tasty and moist, with a bit of spice, but I felt they could have used a little more salt. The center of the pizza was quite thin, which made it difficult to pick up without the toppings sliding off. The pizza pie cost $24 for four slices. While it was good overall, the garlic knots were lacking in salt and were soggy with olive oil and garlic. I placed my order through Uber Eats.

Lucille's is fantastic! Whether you prefer Grandma-style pizza or classic New York slices, we are really happy to have them in our neighborhood.

I ordered a slice of Margherita pizza, and it was quite good. The thin, crispy crust complemented the generous amount of sauce and cheese. I would have preferred a bit more sauce and cheese to better highlight the flavors, but that's a minor detail because overall, it was a great slice. It is on the pricey side, though.

Picture says it all. Completely unacceptable and just awful. And not even a compensation from them. Uber eats was luckily helpful instead of them. Called to tell them and the man said he can’t do anything about. Horrific customer service.

Pizza was decent. i’m from brooklyn and might be spoiled. cheese and crust were good, sauce was a little bland. price was good, $6 for 2 plain slices. not familiar with the area but i’d come back