Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Eileen's Special Cheesecake:
We happen to accidentally stumble upon this place. We came out of eating pizza next door and craved something sweet. We decided to give this place a try. We were definitely not disappointed! This small establishment does not have any seating. No need! After making our selection from a large variety of flavors to choose from, we made our purchase and we stood by the bar next to the window. We looked at NY life through... View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about Eileen's Special Cheesecake:
$6 for a very small 4 bite cheesecake. It’s very soft. I prefer cheesecake a bit more together- not falling apart like cake. Tried the strawberry which was good but one small berry on it. Also took it to go and they put it in a bag- no box… I asked for a box and unless you buy 4- only a bag- which means the glaze was stuck to the paper and it became a mess. That’s bad business in my opinion.
Loved it! I tried the small classic NY cheesecake with a strawberry on top. More of a fluffy texture but a super rich and delicious cheesecake at the same time. Highly recommended!
So glad that I was finally able to trying Eileen's after hearing all of the hype surrounding the cheesecake : The shop itself is rather small, and when I visited, it was takeout only, but there are benches outside where you can sit enjoy your cheesecake. For about $6-8 a cheesecake, I thought that it was rather pricier, but it was definitely worth trying. They have so many different flavors, from original to strawberry to mango, I definitely wish I was able to try more flavors. But the cheesecake itself is so tasty and rich in flavor. Depending on the flavor that you get, some may be dense, whereas others are light and airy.The cheesecakes are premade, so service is pretty fast as well. You can pop right in, grab a cheesecake, and go on about your day. Definitely recommend swinging by if you have the chance.
The best there ever was! A truly heavenly tasting cheesecake that is not overly sweet or heavy. I enjoy a personal sized cutie, that comes in a dozen flavors, every time I am in the area for over 5 years now. They’re one of those delightful Manhattan haunts that’s kept the spirit of the original business owner alive while also retaining the taste and experience.
We happen to accidentally stumble upon this place. We came out of eating pizza next door and craved something sweet. We decided to give this place a try. We were definitely not disappointed! This small establishment does not have any seating. No need! We stood by the bar next to the window as we ate our small sized delicious desserts. The attendant assisting us was very patient as we made our selection.
I’ve had a lot of cheesecake in the New York area. Some good some not so good. This is great cheesecake. The nice thing about it is that if you’re trying to try a few different spots in one day, you can get the bite sized version and not fill up too much on it.I’d definitely go back!
More information
QR-code link to the menu
