Blue Eyed Baker - New York

Do not order online. It provides no benefit. We ordered breakfast sandwiches online for a pickup time 30 minutes from our order, and arrived during the pickup time and waited another 30 minutes, in which they brought the sandwiches out after we asked the status. There was no one ahead of us or waiting in the store. They brought the sandwiches out along with another customer’s order, who arrived 10 minutes after us and ordered sandwiches on the spot. We asked them what the benefit of ordering on … – show

Everything they make is amazing. I can’t get enough of the brioche cinnamon rolls or almond chocolate croissants they always hit the spot. Would highly recommend

Overpriced overbaked croissants. Bought an almond croissant on an early Sunday afternoon. It tasted both stale and greasy. Nice amount of flaky layers, but not too distinct an almond flavor. Would try again, may be better on a different day.

We had BEB do the desert bar at our wedding in May 2022 and I still think about how delicious the cookies were! We had regular cookies, macaroons and cupcakes. Everything was perfect and our guests continuously commented on how good the deserts were. We provided our own dishes and risers for the display table and the BEB team set everything up for us. They were also reasonable with price. Thank you BEB!:

Went to the farmers marked was told they sold out of the maple cookies and the bakery was 5 minutes down the road and they should have some. Drove to the bakery only to be told that they didn't make those cookies today its on a day to day basis. Ordered a cookie, macaron mini cake and lemon tart the lady completely disregard me when I told her what cookie I wanted. She looked me right in the eyes and gave me a diffrent one. Then proceeded to put all three items in this big 12inch cake box. Which … – show