Sheetz - New Stanton

American, Mexican, North American

Sheetz

★ 2.9 / 5 (95 reviews)

Sheetz in New Stanton, PA, is an American restaurant with a 4-star rating. Visit today between 12:00 AM and 11:59 PM, and make a reservation for your party at (724) 635-3054. Don't forget to check out other nearby options like Wendy's and Big Black Grill. Share your dining experience and leave a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Nick

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 2.9 / 5 from 95 reviews

This Sheetz location offers convenient access just off Interstate 70 with ample truck parking and a generally clean, well-kept environment. Many appreciate the friendly staff and busy atmosphere, though some have noted occasional food quality issues such as burnt items or soggy nachos. Customer service experiences vary greatly, with multiple reports of rude management and ID verification problems causing frustration. While the coffee and drink stations are often spotless, some longtime visitors miss the older style coffee service. Overall, the store balances convenience and atmosphere but struggles with consistency in food quality and customer service.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Do not get the sauerkraut on your hot dog. It seems very very old and not warm at all. It just looks like garbage.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Got a MTO peanut butter milkshake their tonight and when i started drinking it all I tasted was nothing but ice.... heres the pics to prove it, learn to do a better job!

12.09.2024

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Almost everyday I buy products from this Sheetz that require ID. I?m 23 and my ID is completely valid. Today though a employee named (Rae) refused service saying my ID wasn?t up to standards . Me , Realizing she didn?t know what she was talking about Iwanted to talk to the manager (Nathanael) who also refused service with attitude also. I then went to GetGo and they supplies mewith service and said my ID was fine. The management/employees are rude and they always burn my food. Terrible employees.Multiple people I know have had issues with said (Nathanael) (Rae)

Nick

12.09.2024

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

I love Sheetz. All but this one! I got nachos (which you don't have the option to get toppings on the side if your order online) and when I picked them up the were so terrible! Soggy and completely cold. The employees are not at all friendly besides a few.Terrible service, terrible food. Do NOT go to this Sheetz! I promise you're better off!

Michael

12.09.2024

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Sheetz is generally a dependable choice for a quick meal, but this particular location disappointed me. I ordered a spicy chicken sandwich with extra Buffalo sauce, ranch dressing, and lettuce. Unfortunately, it came without any condiments, and the chicken was partially burned and incredibly tough. I can overlook an occasional missing condiment, but since the restaurant wasn't busy, I can't fathom how someone thought that chicken was acceptable to serve. I still plan to visit Sheetz in the future, but I will certainly steer clear of this location.

Feedback