Taster's - New Madrid

Italian, Pizza, Delivery Services
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Taster's

Taster's
4.2 / 5 (32 reviews)

Menu

On this webpage, you will find the complete menu of Taster's from New Madrid. Currently, there are 6 dishes and drinks available.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Kimberly

Images

Taster's Menu

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 32 reviews

Was User at Taster's a mag?
Taster's is a pretty solid local restaurant. They offer the best pizza in the city by a long shot, as well as quite tasty burgers and hot sandwiches. My only complaints are that they consistently seem to have issues with their ice machine, and the burgers are a bit pricey for what they are—I suspect they're using frozen, preformed patties rather than hand-formed ones. However, they do cook the burgers fresh when you... View all feedback.

What User dislikes about Taster's:
The waitress used inappropriate language while addressing the staff members. They had stopped serving drinks, which didn’t seem very sanitary. I asked for a nostalgic dish from my childhood, but they only had 10 fries available. They mentioned they needed to weigh them first. Where is that coming from? View all feedback.

The waitress used inappropriate language while addressing the staff members. They had stopped serving drinks, which didn’t seem very sanitary. I asked for a nostalgic dish from my childhood, but they only had 10 fries available. They mentioned they needed to weigh them first. Where is that coming from?

menupix-user-rabbit1-23
31.03.2024

The waitress was using inappropriate language towards employees who were off the clock and had simply stopped by to grab a drink. It didn't feel very sanitary. I ordered a kids' meal, which only came with 10 fries. When I asked about it, I was told they had to weigh the fries. Where was the management during all this?

menupix-user-church5-19
31.03.2024

Taster's is a solid hometown restaurant that stands out for having the best pizza in town, by far. Their burgers and hot sandwiches are also quite good. However, I do have a couple of complaints. They often seem to have issues with their ice cream machine, which is a bit frustrating. Additionally, the burgers are a bit on the pricey side for what they offer; it seems like they use frozen preformed patties rather than hand-shaped ones, though they are cooked to order. The food is consistently served hot, and I’ve never encountered any problems in that regard. I do wish they would consider elevating the overall ambiance—upgrading to nicer tables, giving the place a fresh coat of paint, or adding some curtains could really enhance the experience.

kimberly-jackson-tn
31.03.2024

It's been over a year since I last visited New Madrid, but now that I'm pregnant, I've been craving Taster's dishes—especially their corn nuggets!

I haven't visited New Madrid in over a year, but now that I'm pregnant, I'm craving some tasty treats. I'm especially eager to try her corn nuggets!

Full Menu

More information

QR-Code for the menu

QR-Code zur Speisekarte von Taster's

Suggested nearby restaurants.