Taster's - New Madrid

Italian, Pizza, Delivery Services

Taster's

Taster's
4.2 / 5 (32 reviews)

Description

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Verlie

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 32 reviews
kimberly-jackson-tn
31.03.2024

It's been over a year since I last visited New Madrid, but now that I'm pregnant, I've been craving Taster's dishes—especially their corn nuggets!

menupix-user-rabbit1-23
31.03.2024

The waitress was using inappropriate language towards employees who were off the clock and had simply stopped by to grab a drink. It didn't feel very sanitary. I ordered a kids' meal, which only came with 10 fries. When I asked about it, I was told they had to weigh the fries. Where was the management during all this?

menupix-user-church5-19
31.03.2024

Taster's is a solid hometown restaurant that stands out for having the best pizza in town, by far. Their burgers and hot sandwiches are also quite good. However, I do have a couple of complaints. They often seem to have issues with their ice cream machine, which is a bit frustrating. Additionally, the burgers are a bit on the pricey side for what they offer; it seems like they use frozen preformed patties rather than hand-shaped ones, though they are cooked to order. The food is consistently served hot, and I’ve never encountered any problems in that regard. I do wish they would consider elevating the overall ambiance—upgrading to nicer tables, giving the place a fresh coat of paint, or adding some curtains could really enhance the experience.

verlie04
29.01.2023

I haven't visited New Madrid in over a year, but now that I'm pregnant, I'm craving some tasty treats. I'm especially eager to try her corn nuggets!

everette75
29.01.2023

Taster's is a pretty solid local restaurant. They offer the best pizza in the city by a long shot, as well as quite tasty burgers and hot sandwiches. My only complaints are that they consistently seem to have issues with their ice machine, and the burgers are a bit pricey for what they are—I suspect they're using frozen, preformed patties rather than hand-formed ones. However, they do cook the burgers fresh when you order, so they're always hot and I've never had an issue with that. I just wish they would inject a bit more creativity into their offerings and invest in some nicer tables, a fresh coat of paint, new curtains, or something to elevate the atmosphere.

FAQ

As a visitor, you can use the WLAN of the restaurant free of charge.

More information

QR-Code for the menu

QR-Code zur Speisekarte von Taster's

Suggested nearby restaurants.