Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Noah Fulkroad likes about Culhane's Steak House:
Nice spot for a home cooked meal. Not as fancy as the Steak House name would imply. Food was decent, but left a little to be desired in terms of flavor. Veggies seemed like they came out of the steamer with no salt or pepper. Chicken was a tad on the dry side. Service was great though and atmosphere was very nice. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner View all feedback.
What Robert Draper doesn't like about Culhane's Steak House:
Wife and I stopped here for lunch today. Resturant was empty except the staff and us. Ordered the demonic steak, potato, and salad. The salad was lettuce and a single tomato. Then came the steak and potato. The steak came out on a sizzling plate that continued to over cook the outside of alrwady tough the steak, which had no flavor at all. I have had better cuts of meat at a diner. The potato had a cheese sauce from... View all feedback.
Went to Culhane's for the first time recently when we visited PA for an event in New Cumberland. Our server was Drew and she was the best. Very attentive throughout our visit. Drew did not have to be asked to refill our soft drinks or water. Our orders were 100% correct when they came out. We both had the Porterhouse Steak (on a sizzling skill) and it was tender in your mouth. They give you a knife, but it wasn't necessary... it could be cut with a fork. The salad was fresh like the veggies. The app of Scallops was cooked to perfection, came hot and was seasoned well. The quality of the food was surpassed only by the great service of Drew. We recommended it to the friends and they went there next night. We'll return safely.
Update 2: the food is still great. Something I noted is their cocktails are rather affordable considering they are a steak house. For example their well bourbon a gingerale is 4.25, and upgrading to a makers is only 6.25. This seems veryreasonable to me. Update: we stopped in for dinner again. They were out of my favorite draft beer, the Bells, but I found one of my favorite beers in a bottle. Tonight we had the nachos with chicken, the garlic parm wings, and the kids steak. All were very good, check out the pictures. Service was good, but a little slow. We will be back again. My wife and I have been here a few times and really enjoy it here. The corn nuggets are amazing and we've been getting them recently. The Jumbo lump stuffed flounder with imperial sauce was very good and most recently I had the burger, which was very good. The seating can be a little weird though. We sat in the front area to the right of the stairs in front of the bar area and it was strangely quiet. There was no music and the acoustics seem off, so we try to request other seating when we are there.
Awesome steakhouse to visit. The steaks were delicious. Service was great. Plenty of parking , Definitely stopping in again.
When I lived in New Cumberland, it was a weekly treat! Never had a negative experience.
Culhane's been a long time ago. The food is remarkably always so consistently excellent. Steaks are good and also their seafood. House Dressing is dying for...