Mellow Mushroom New Albany

This was our first time here and from the moment we got there we had an amazing experience !!!! The greeter was so nice and then our waitress, Paige and Johnny were so kind and will definitely be back! !!! We can definitely tell that the team works cohesively !

This was our first visit here, and let me tell you... I'm pretty sure that we've found a new favorite place to eat!! The second we walked in the door the we were totally digging the atmosphere, I mean you can never go wrong with C3PO, R2D2 Yoda greeting you at the front entrance foyer! Once we were inside the restaurant we were immediately greeted by Sydney and seated at a table. Sydney was also our server, and quickly took our drink order. He ordered Coca-Cola and I got plain Tea. When she came back with our drinks she immediately took our lunch order. We decided to try the Magic Mushroom Soup to start off with, which came out quickly and did not disappoint!! It was so creamy and it was like a mushroom flavor explosion in your mouth! We both agreed that regular mushroom soup would never ever be the same. Lol. For lunch he ordered the Sausagefest Calzone with a side of Spicy Ranch. I ordered The Elevated Cobb Salad without tomatoes (allergic) and the Balsamic Vinegarette dressing. Once our lunches came out we were even more thrilled with this place. The portions were huge, and the flavor on both of our lunches was frikin amazing!! He could only eat about 1/2 of his Calzone and I probably only got through about 1/4 of my salad. So we asked for to go boxes, and Sydney immediately asked us if we wanted to also take our drinks and if we'd like a bag to carry everything. Sydney's service was phenomenal! She was always pleasant, and had a smile on her face and truly looked like she enjoyed her job! In fact, every employee we encountered was also smiling and pleasant.

Worst and most expensive pizza I've ever bought I've had Lil Caesars that is better. Missing toppings(bacon) the dough was undercooked and still raw. Mostly crust. Legit 16 inch it had 6 inches of crust. The toppings were so sparce that each piece had one on it. Only way I ate half was cooking it when I got home. Was a horrible experience would not recommend.

Total garbage experience. Ordered online during a dead time between lunch and dinner. Had a pickup time 45m later. Showed up 5m later than my time and they still hadn’t made the damn pizzas. They have me wait while they run around like chickens with their heads cut off, lost and confused. They then tell me they never started the pizza and it would be another 45 minutes. Will never come back again. Horrible customer service

I have never been disappointed at this restaurant. The pizza is always fresh and hot, but be prepared to wait a bit - it's worth it. It has a family-friendly atmosphere that appeals to all age groups. My friends and I love to visit different places in the area, and this restaurant is always a nice option for a delicious meal and some ice cream afterwards.