Panthers Pizza - Nappanee

I really enjoy your pizza, but I'm really frustrated with how often I order cheese sauce and it doesn't end up in my box. When you pay for something, you should... read more I really enjoy your pizza, but I'm really frustrated with how often I order cheese sauce and it doesn't end up in my box. When you pay for something, you should receive it!

It's a bit on the expensive side, but the portions are generous and the food is excellent. read more It's a bit on the expensive side, but the portions are generous and the food is excellent.

I ordered the spaghetti carry out, It was horrible. Noddles had no flavor and the meatballs tasted frozen. I took 2 bites and threw it away!! It cost about 15$... read more I ordered the spaghetti carry out, It was horrible. Noddles had no flavor and the meatballs tasted frozen. I took 2 bites and threw it away!! It cost about 15$ for that. I can go to a sit down Italian restaurant and have shrimp in my bowl for less. I’m very disappointed and we get pizza there a lot not sure I will be going back.

This restaurant is well-maintained, serves tasty food, and has a welcoming owner! read more This restaurant is well-maintained, serves tasty food, and has a welcoming owner!

Delivery guys was nice , pizza itself was disgusting WAY overpriced. great pizza from pizza hut, dominos, papa john’s are cheaper and way better tasting. it tas... read more Delivery guys was nice , pizza itself was disgusting WAY overpriced. great pizza from pizza hut, dominos, papa john’s are cheaper and way better tasting. it tasted expired, rancid. like medal??? no flavor from any sauce cheese or topping. orders a 16in 3 topping pizza and it’s was $27???? was super hungry and excited to try this but will not be going back, whole house disappointed. wish i could get a refund.