Renzo's Pizza - Mount Sinai

I visited the restaurant on a whim and decided to order dessert first—no regrets! The staff was delightful and cheerful. I ended up staying for dinner, which was excellent and very fresh. They even brewed a pot of coffee just for me. I couldn't resist snapping a picture of the restaurant because it was so beautiful. I plan to return for gift certificates to encourage more people to check it out. Overall, it was a fantastic experience!

We ordered takeout tonight to celebrate our wedding anniversary, and the food was amazing! We had a large cheese pizza, veal parmesan with spaghetti tossed in oil and garlic, tortellini alla vodka, and penne with marinara and meatballs. The portions were generous, everything was fresh and flavorful, the meat was tender, and it was all packed securely for our trip home. Our oldest son, who is autistic and tends to be a picky eater, absolutely loved the penne and meatballs! Thank you for such delicious food!

Fantastic staff and delicious food! I highly recommend this restaurant to everyone. It's the best pizza in Port Jefferson!

The best food in town with the nicest people running it and working in it. Homemade desserts and fresh food. You can't beat it!!!

Best ever! only place we go for pizza never a disappointment