Butcher Boy - Mount Sinai

Came for the first and last time today. Got some ribs and they didn’t tell me they were FROZEN and I didn’t find out until I went to cook them a couple hours later. Totally ruined my dinner since you can’t slow cook ribs from frozen! Plus the place is just kind of sad, half empty and just feels like the products can’t be fresh. I’ll stick with Cow Palace even if it can be a few extra minutes to get to sometimes.

I come here routinely and everyone is so nice and helpful and everything I get has always been so good

I’m not a fan. They have no meat out so they give you what they have. No selection. I just bought 2 filets at $50/lb And they were frozen. I wound up going to cow palace. Great selection of everything and got 2 really nice pieces of filet for $19/lb. I’ll never set foot in butcher boy again

There's no better butcher In the world! Fantastic prices, very clean, and the freshest meat anywhere. I live in montauk and I wouldn't go anywhere else. The staff are the kindest most helpful genuine people you will ever meet. Overall if I could give a rating 11/10.

Always super friendly and helpful! Supports the local schools! My family has never had a complaint about quality of meats and other foods offered. Generous portions as well!!