Eatalian Pizza - Mount Forest

The pizza slices are quite good for the price. However, I ordered wings with mild sauce, and what I received was a disappointing, overly spicy pizza sauce. The wedges were flat instead of being actual wedges, which made for a disappointing game night dinner. Since it was my first time using their delivery service, I was also put off to see that the delivery person wasn’t wearing a mask, which I found unacceptable. I will definitely not be ordering from here again.

Date: August 17, 2021 After enjoying the best pizza I've ever had, I returned and ordered two panzerotti. All I can say is WOW!!! If only Google had a 10-star rating system! They take the time to bake their panzerotti (unlike those fast pizza places that deep-fry them), which is a much healthier option. Eatalian Pizza does not skimp on ingredients at all. Our panzerotti were completely stuffed with the three toppings we chose. Many places leave a lot of empty crust around the edges, but Eatalian Pizza fills their dough right to the edge. You won't be disappointed if you order a panzerotti. We got their Panzo Special for $16.99 (plus tax), which included two three-topping panzerotti, two cans of soda, and a choice of two dipping sauces. You can't beat that price for such an AMAZINGLY TASTY panzerotti! This is definitely the best pizza and panzerotti spot in town. Make sure to check them out in Mount Forest! Apologies for not having a picture this time—I just couldn't stop eating, and by the time I remembered to take a photo, my panzerotti was gone! Date: August 7, 2021 Everything was AMAZING! They truly don't hold back on the toppings. I ordered a Party Combo that included three pizzas, two pounds of wings, cheesy garlic bread, dips, and soda. The pizza was fantastic, the wings were large and meaty, and the garlic bread was loaded with cheese. No more "brand name" pizza places for us; Eatalian Pizza is our #1 choice now! I can't wait to try their panzerotti next time. Give this place a try—you will NOT be disappointed!

It's a good pizza place! The pizza is consistently decent, and the prices are very reasonable. Service is quick, and they can efficiently handle large orders with just a couple of minutes' notice.

Latest update: The Chicken Shawarma Poutine is absolutely heavenly on my fries. I'm in love! When it comes to pizza, I'm usually hard to impress, but this one has me craving more! I'm also excited to hear that the wraps are coming soon!

The pizza is a bit heavy, and the sauce could definitely use some improvement. However, the quality and portion size you get for the price is unbeatable! I would also recommend the chicken wings; they are juicy and well-cooked, and I will definitely order them again. Update: the chicken shawarma poutine was delicious!