Cattleman's Club Steakhouse - Mitchell
Cattleman's Club Steakhouse
Menu
Here you will find the menu of Cattleman's Club Steakhouse in Mitchell. At the moment, there are 59 meals and drinks on the list.
Cattleman's Club in Mitchell, SD, is a renowned American dining destination, proudly holding an impressive average rating of 4 stars. Join us for an unforgettable meal from 5:00 PM to 10:00 PM today! To ensure you don't miss out, be sure to reserve your table by calling (605) 990-2222 in advance. Prefer to dine at home? You can conveniently order your favorite dishes through DoorDash. If you're exploring similar menu options, consider also visiting Pizza Ranch and McDonald's. We would love to hear about your experience—leave a review after your meal!.
Images
Feedback
Cattleman's Club has garnered mixed reviews, showcasing a contrast between delightful dining experiences and significant service shortcomings. Many patrons praise the delicious steaks and attentive staff, particularly highlighting the ribeye and porterhouse as exceptional choices. However, instances of poor service, such as long wait times and unprofessional behavior from bartenders, have left some customers frustrated. While the food quality, including fresh salads and prime rib, often impresses, a lack of consistency in service dampens the overall experience. Ultimately, this restaurant holds potential for great meals, but diners may need to manage expectations regarding service.
Came in right before close. Almost everyone had food (keep in mind there were only two other tables) but my medium rare steak took over 30 minutes to come out. While I was there, there were two bartenders. One was working and doing stuff to close while the other one sat with who looked like the boss/manager and was holding hands, leaning on, and very publicly showing affection. Very disappointed in the lack of professionalism even though the food was decent. Ruined my experience that I had to watch that while eating.
This is the worst service I have ever experienced! The burger for my 8-year-old came out cooked to a medium rare at best. When we brought it up, all they offered to do was throw the partially eaten burger back on the grill or make a new one. By that time, my child had lost their appetite, so we requested for it to be removed from the bill. However, we were told that they do not do that at this restaurant. When I tried to explain that the burger was undercooked, I was told that I should have mentioned it earlier.
This was the best meal I've had in a while. I ordered the 24oz porterhouse cooked medium rare and it was done perfectly! I can't wait to return. The value for the meal was also great.
As a truck driver I get to eat at several steakhouses around the county. This place is wonderful. Keep in mind, its a little pricey but remember, you get what you pay for. Staff was all smiles and very friendly. Our waitress (Frankie) made us feel athome, put smiles on our face, and was honest as to what was best for our taste this evening. We usually try to cover all theground we can, but this place is going to make us take a day when passing through and be sure to stop. Comfortable walk to andfrom the truckstop as well.
The worst service I?ve ever experienced! My 8 year olds burger came out cooked at medium rare at best. We said something and all that was done was we were told that they could throw the (already partially eaten) burger BACK on the grill or cook us a newone. By that point my child had lost their appetite so we asked them to take it off the bill. We were told ?we don?t do thathere?. When I tried to explain that the burger was not done I was told you should have told the server to have it cooked welldone. The owner argued with us on how the burger was cooked. He said it is medium well. Sorry but that?s almost raw. Wewere told ? sorry we won?t do anything for you? and walked away. He had no regards to customer service in any way shape orform.
Full Menu
Dishes
Lil' Shovers Steak BitesDinner Raw Bar
Chilled Shrimp DinnerHand-Cut Steaks
16 Oz. Boneless Ribeye
16 Oz. Top Sirloin
Ron's Pile
24 Oz. Bone-In Ribeye
More information
QR-Code for the menu

This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 3.5 / 5 (2819 reviews)Burgers Salad American Steak Ice CreamRuby Tuesday
Highland Way 1900, 57301 Mitchell, US
"Great service!! Great servers!! Great food!! Thanks!!"
★ 4.7 / 5 (1101 reviews)Breakfast Coffee American ItalianCaribou Coffee
W Havens Ave 1305, 57301 Mitchell, US
"Good coffee and clean shop front. Pricey but nothing comes cheap"
★ 3.3 / 5 (24 reviews)#10 Fast Food in Mitchell CateringSubway
802 North Sanborn Boulevard, Mitchell, SD 57301, United States
"Thanks for the coupons, otherwise I couldnt eat here."