Millburn Deli

#35 - Pizza - Millburn, American, Delis
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +19733795800
Reservation
Reservation request for Millburn Deli.

Menu

On this website, you will find the complete menu of Millburn Deli from Millburn. Currently, there are 26 dishes and drinks available.

Millburn Deli, a beloved fixture in Millburn, NJ, is celebrated for its delectable American cuisine and boasts an impressive average rating of 4.6 stars. Join us this week from 9:00 AM to 5:30 PM to experience our inviting atmosphere and delicious offerings. To ensure you secure a table, feel free to call ahead at (973) 379-5800. Prefer to dine at home? Enjoy our scrumptious meals delivered straight to your door via DoorDash. Interested in exploring similar menu options? Be sure to check out Gong Cha and Basilico. If you've visited us before, we’d love to hear your thoughts—leave a review!.

Last update: 12.12.2025 from: User

Images

Millburn Deli Food Millburn Deli Food Millburn Deli Outside Millburn Deli Menu Millburn Deli Food Millburn Deli Food Millburn Deli Food Millburn Deli Food

Reservation request for Millburn Deli

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 43377 reviews

Millburn Deli stands out as a beloved destination for sandwich enthusiasts, praised for its fresh ingredients and extensive menu. While some patrons have pointed out inconsistencies in sandwich preparation and portion sizes, others rave about the deliciousness of their pressed sandwiches, particularly the pastrami and Sausalito Turkey Sloppy Joe. The inviting atmosphere, complete with quirky decor and fast service, enhances the dining experience. Though some have suggested improvements to gluten-free options, the overall sentiment is one of loyalty and satisfaction, making this deli a must-visit—even if it requires a bit of a journey.

ews
Ews 21.10.2023 - 16:01

Absolutely delicious sandwich! I was passing by and remember Nj?s famous sloppy Joe?s.. one to get, not to forget.. I would come back again for sure!!

john-l-horse6
John 21.10.2023 - 16:01

I will say that their chicken cutlet sub with bacon and cheese was very fresh, tasty and not lacking anything. Good pickle on the side too. BUT That being said, to charge about $10 for an Italian sub that only has 1 or MAYBE 2 slices of ham and same with salami, how can this be described as fair? I?m a little disappointed with the cold sandwich meat portions. They should at least be thicker than a normal persons pinky finger. I guess I?ll just have to make a mental note to stay away from their cold sandwiches.

vincent-liao
Vincent 21.10.2023 - 16:01

An exceptional deli. Great sandwich bread, quality ingredients, and efficient service. I got the Perfect Ten and corned beef and pastrami sloppy Joe. Both really tasty sandwiches. I traveled 30 miles to get here and was not disappointed. I will probably come back to grab lunch when I visit South Mountain.

Love this deli first time in this location in Milburn and the selections are vast and many. Being new I was thankful no one rushed me as I took the time to review the various menus of which there were many many menu and sandwich selection boards.Prices were reasonable, sandwiches were nice sized and the salads were a very good portion. Service was fast, all the foodtasted great and I will go back. Oh yeah added bonus there's a park a few feet away so grab a meal and have a picnic.

I don?t get what all the fuss is about. This is their TWO meat sloppy Joe. Can you see the tiny amount peaking under the mountain of coleslaw? So soggy with nothing but sopping coleslaw on two layers that it fell apart. The other Italian sub hadonly two of the 3 meats?! Seriously not worth the money, the long wait or the hype. Would rather have driven to the city for aCarnegie Deli or Katz sandwich where you really get your worth!

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.