Clemenza's Original Brick Oven

#23 - Pizza - Millburn, Italian, Pickup
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Clemenza's Original Brick Oven

Clemenza's Original Brick Oven
4.4 / 5 (609 reviews)

Description

**Dining at Clemenza's: A Mixed Bag of Experiences**

Clemenza’s has captivated many with its inviting atmosphere and promising menu, but recent visits reveal a decline in consistency and service. While some patrons rave about the quality of the pizza, praising its fresh ingredients and flavorful crust, others have encountered issues like missing toppings and extended wait times. The burger offerings have also garnered criticism; diners have found them overpriced for the quality provided. Despite these setbacks, the establishment continues to attract customers with its charming ambiance and dedicated staff. For those seeking a satisfying meal, exploring the menu may yield favorable options amidst the fluctuations.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Norval

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 609 reviews
vschiller-5
10.04.2025

Clemenza?s was our go-to every Friday for pizza since we moved here 1.5 years ago. Unfortunately it?s gone downhill in the last few months, either with pick up times being very off or items missing from no pepperoni on the requested half of the pizza, toblue cheese missing with chicken wings, ricotta cheese mixed in with meatballs instead of on the side as stated etc. We alwaysseem to be emailing to get credited back for missing items lately. I also started ordering our dinner supper early (3 pm) toavoid any crazy rush but come to find it is still taking a very long time and not as originally stated for pick up.

itorp-beach24
10.04.2025

There were no other patrons here at 5:15 and that should hav been my first clue. We sat outside. But the food was mediocre at best. It would have been worth it for a $10 burger. It was not worth the $18 we paid for a burger. The french fries were bad.The onion rings were great. I would probably explore more options if I had a choice next time

sbecker-chef7562
10.04.2025

Ordered a large pizza with three toppings, only got two toppings, people at the store didn?t care, put us on hold for 30 minutes just to tell us they don?t care. Just the worst service in town and not even the best pizza among the many options here. Sad,hope a decent business comes in to replace them soon.

herzog-pearl
10.04.2025

I do like Clamenzas pizza, and would recommend it. But had a horrible experience with a simple cheesesteak, to go. I called it in via phone, and ordered a cheesteak, with fried onions, and I specifically said, NO peppers as sometimes that's a standard ona Cheesesteak. It was ready upon my arrival, and when I got home, I opened the bag and there was a huge roll, with 2 oz, yes 2oz, of steak meat, a smear of cheese and a few slivers of fried onions... ALSO on the sandwich were 10, red bliss potatoes splitin 1/2, on the roll with the 2 oz of steak meat. What a disappointment... certainly I didnt ask for potatoes, nor should i havehad to think to say, by the way, no potatoes... who has ever heard of such a thing, potatoes on a huge roll... the meat was likea garnish to the thing. I took off the 10 halves of the potatoes, as I don't like potatoes, not even a little.. I was left withthe 2oz of steak meat, a little cheese, and a few slivers of onions.. In this community, we are not fooled by big rolls andpotatoes, to bulk up 2 oz of steak meat... never again LaStrada and Gian Marco make a good cheeseteak, I'll stick withthem If I had time to go back, I would have returned the thing

sandy-g-engineer2
23.11.2023

Yes!! Clemenzas, good food, if want something fast see if just having nice meal, and it's convenient , close by ! Their service id very good! If she'll want anything ! Their on it! I like them personally ! Clemency yes' would suggest to anymore waht pizza lol hungry

FAQ

A little farther located is Njt - Millburn Station, where you can also access the municipal transportation.

As a customer, you can use the WiFi of the establishment free of charge.

The place offers you a choice of gluten-free meals.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.