The Slice Pie - Middletown

I had my pizza delivered through door dash and the actual dough was hard first time I ever ordered from there and will be the last 40 dollar pizza SMH read more I had my pizza delivered through door dash and the actual dough was hard first time I ever ordered from there and will be the last 40 dollar pizza SMH

The bartender .. well she was a sweet heart. The day I was in there someone walked in and tried to rob the place and she stood her ground and the perp ran off.... read more The bartender .. well she was a sweet heart. The day I was in there someone walked in and tried to rob the place and she stood her ground and the perp ran off. God bless her for being so brave?

Stopped here for lunch while on our Middletown adventure. Waitress friendly and service was great. Pizza was amazing. read more Stopped here for lunch while on our Middletown adventure. Waitress friendly and service was great. Pizza was amazing.

Good food and great music. My favorite band is criticalkhaos read more Good food and great music. My favorite band is criticalkhaos

When I lived abroad, coming home to see my family, stopping by The Slice was a highlight of my trip as I would always take my brother there. Just him and I, a f... read more When I lived abroad, coming home to see my family, stopping by The Slice was a highlight of my trip as I would always take my brother there. Just him and I, a few brews and delicious pie. Unfortunately, I can't say that it is what it once was. I need the owners to know that it's slipping. If a single can of beer is going to be $7, then the pizza HAS to have sauce. If the kitchen is out of toppings, the customer needs to be informed when they order.The $20 pep pie was served with no sauce. The cheese coagulated into a gum that was stuck to the crust with no sauce. Sauce is flavor. It's the largest cheat code in all of pizza. If there's no sauce, the cheap cheese turns to gum and ruins the crust.The Everything slices that were ordered were done so since we noticed last year that pizza by the slice was better than an entire pie. This time, VERY little sauce, cheese, pepperoni, but all the veg, the veg that kitchen had in stock, seemed to have been tossed on after the pie came out of the oven. ...I am pleading with management, owners, kitchen staff, anyone who will listen. Please return to the awesome pizza gem that The Slice used to be. When we walked in, I was upset because it was completely empty on a Sunday at 5 pm. I mentioned that we would have to eat here more often and support the restaurant before we lose it. Sadly, it must be said that I do not plan on returning to what was my favorite pizza spot unless the quality seriously comes back around. $30 for 4 cans of Blue Moon was a surprise, but not nearly as disappointing as coming to the conclusion that whoever is running the kitchen, their heart is not this anymore.I didn't have the heart to say anything at the time. We ate a few slices, had our beers, I paid the check, and we left. Family commented later about sending the pie back and refusing to pay for it, but again, that's not in me. The lady tending the bar was very nice, and of course, I tipped her. She didn't make the pizzas. She was even kind enough to get us little cups of sauce to dip our slices in.I just... this was my favorite place.I hate criticism as people usually get overly defensive, and all they hear is that they are getting blamed for something. I just want good pizza.