Mulligans - Middletown

American, Cheese, Sandwiches
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Mulligans

Mulligans
4.3 / 5 (177 reviews)

Description

Mulligan's boasts a warm atmosphere and friendly service, making it a great spot for casual dining and relaxation. Diners have praised the delicious food, particularly the Chicken Salad Wrap, and the attentive staff. However, several guests have expressed frustration with noise levels and inconsistent service, particularly during busy events like the Super Bowl. Issues with reservations and timing have also been noted, as some meals arrived simultaneously with appetizers. While the overall experience has its ups and downs, many highlight Mulligan's as a pleasant neighborhood bar worth a visit for unwinding with friends.

Last update: 26.02.2026 from: JNTenor

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 177 reviews
billa
01.10.2023

This is a charming neighborhood bar with a warm atmosphere and friendly vibe. The food was excellent, and the beer was served ice cold. It's the ideal spot to enjoy a complete meal, appetizers, or just some drinks while you unwind. Everyone there was friendly and laid-back, creating a fun environment filled with hard-working individuals looking to relax. We’ll definitely be returning and will recommend this place to many others.

maggie
01.10.2023

We came to Mulligan's with our new neighbors to give it a try. I don't think he was pleased with his chicken wings. Our steak sandwich was fine but the cole slaw is a no go. Celery seed really? No way. Our server Sage was very good, he had a good sense of humor. Not sure if we will be back, way to loud for us.

lissiemo
01.10.2023

Great FOOD and service. The restaurant needs 'acoustic panels ' to absorb all of the NOISE. There was rain in the forecast which is why we sat inside. Server was very attentive.

jntenor
01.10.2023

Great Food Great Service Clean Restaurant Follows Covid-19 Protocols

jntenor
01.10.2023

Great food Great service Clean restaurant They follow all Covid-19 protocols

Menu

  • Main

    Mulligans Salad*
    Mulligans Salad*

    Spring mix + grilled chicken; avocado; sliced almonds & fresh strawberries

    $15.1
    Beef Battered Fish And Chips
    Beef Battered Fish And Chips

    Served + house cut fries & coleslaw

    $14.1
    Pappardelle Alfredo Pasta
    Pappardelle Alfredo Pasta

    Pappardelle pasta + fresh garlic & fresh parmesan cheese in a house made cream sauce

    $14.1
    Caroline Pulled Pork
    Caroline Pulled Pork
    $13.1
  • Omelets

    Mulligan Omelet
    Mulligan Omelet

    3 egg omelet + bacon; sausage; ham & cheddar. Served + hash browns & toast

    $12.1
  • House Specialties

    Delaware Burger
    Delaware Burger

    Our burger served + scrapple; Egg up; American cheese; & an Onion ring on a brioche roll + a side of house cut fries

    $17.2

FAQ

The place also takes credit cards from the common providers as a means of payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.