Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What DeathsownProductions likes about Cataldo's Pizzeria:
Was a wonderful experience. My family comes from back east and a good ol Italian nostalgic family NY style Pizzeria with real taste is a rare thing to come by out here ?That being said this nailed it all the way around. I just got a place down the street and I'll beaking this my go to at least once a week ? ? View all feedback.
What Jeremy L doesn't like about Cataldo's Pizzeria:
Me and my wife waited 2 hours for our pizza to be delivered just for the delivery guy to tell us that he had to go home check his kids and then he had car trouble and the owner never called us back so we will never go back and when we got our pizza it was ice cold and we live one minute away from cataldo's with a red light it took me 1 minute if the owner cared he would have called us so he doesn't care about his bus... View all feedback.
We enjoyed the Chicken with mushrooms and extra cheese.Also the Pepperoni with extra cheese. Disappointed with Cannoli. I didn't taste ricotta cheese the filling tasted pure sugar icing and extremely sweet.The man at the counter was really nice and accommodating.
Ordered take out..spaghetti was great but wish more meatballs were served with it and salad and lasagne were great all with a decent price!
It's always good time when ordering Pizza and logs from here. The Chili Verde is the best!
I am only giving a 1 star review because there's not an option for negative stars. My family and I have been loyal, regular customers of Cataldos for years now. We usually love their pizza and the service used to be awesome. However recently the food has not been as good because they changed their ovens. On March 15th we ordered 2 large pizzas and breadsticks for delivery from the website. I ordered at 6:18 pm. At 6:47 pm their website said my order was picked up. By 7:11 almost 30 mins later my food was not delivered. I called the store and was informed that my order was still there, that the driver was still waiting. I told her ok no problem, I just didn't want cold food. At 8:11 Pm the driver arrived, jumped out of the passenger side of the vehicle with my food. Said sorry I had car trouble. My food was COLD, THE BOTTOM OF THE BOXES WERE SOGGY!....um...NOPE.... we went to the store with all of the food unopened and uneaten. Asked for a refund and for the owner to give me a call. I have received no call from anyone as of yet. I am pissed and will not be ordering from here again. 2 hours and almost 70 dollars for cold pizza is unacceptable. Especially with the delivery address being 1 minute away.
Me and my wife waited 2 hours for our pizza to be delivered just for the delivery guy to tell us that he had to go home check his kids and then he had car trouble and the owner never called us back so we will never go back and when we got our pizza it was ice cold and we live one minute away from cataldo's with a red light it took me 1 minute if the owner cared he would have called us so he doesn't care about his business
Full Menu
Pizza
Sides
Main Courses
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
More information
QR-code link to the menu
