Third Eye Pies - Mercer

#7 - Pizza - Mercer, Lunch, Magpie
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Third Eye Pies

Third Eye Pies
4.5 / 5 (2240 reviews)

Description

Third Eye Pies in Mercer, PA, is a highly-rated American restaurant, celebrated for its delicious offerings and an impressive average rating of 4.5 stars. Diners rave about their experiences, so be sure to stop by! Today, Third Eye Pies is open from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM. To avoid the rush, consider calling ahead to secure your table at (724) 748-6464. If you prefer dining at home, you can conveniently order from Third Eye Pies through DoorDash. The menu also features a variety of vegetarian options. Intrigued by the menu but want to explore similar dining experiences? Check out Pampered Palate Cafe Bistro in Grove City and Independent Taco. Have you had the pleasure of dining here before?.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: User

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 2240 reviews

The pizza restaurant was amazing. The pizzas were fresh, homemade, and ready to eat in a few minutes. They were cooked in a wood oven for a few minutes. We had the Nashville Hot Chicken and Chicken Parmesan Pizzas and they were delicious. The staff werealso courteous during the process. The restaurant was also clean and had lots of tables. I highly recommend this place becauseit was a good value for money.

I had the Last Supper on a regular crust. It was really tasty. Plenty of toppings. My husband did his own choice on a cauliflower crust, and he really enjoyed it. He is in love with the garlic sauce!

I can?t understand how this place has so many good reviews? I?d give zero stars if possible. We stumbled in unbiased after a trip to Keystone Safari. The logo and imagery is horrible clip art based chaos. You can barely read all the menus on the tv?sbecause of the horrible design, placement, and clutter. Incredibly confusing. The ingredients don?t appear fresh at all. Thedough looked to be frozen. Way too much cheese. Way too much sauce. Sauce too sweet. Asked for ?garlic butter? on the crust as alast ditch way to make it edible. The young lady DRENCHED it. My pie was a hot greasy mess. My wife?s was too. Then happened tonotice all the sauces sitting out without refrigeration. Many of them dairy based. Gross. Seems like they?re placed perfectlyby the outlets to draw in parents and kids to their gimmicky bad quality restaurant. I genuinely enjoyed nothing about this place. What a waste of a pizza oven and location. If you have any taste for quality food at all, don?t come here.

After my fourth visit, I’m completely in love with Third Eye Pies. Since I can’t eat gluten, finding delicious gluten-free options is rare, but the choices here are fantastic! My favorite pizza so far is the chef-inspired Club Med with cauliflower crust. I’m totally hooked!

Third Eye Pies is a fantastic build-your-own pizza spot with a wide selection of toppings, including dessert options. The staff are incredibly friendly, and the space is spotless with well-maintained equipment. I would definitely return.

FAQ

The restaurant offers free WLAN for its customers.

The diner is accessible and can therefore also be used with a wheelchair or physiological disabilities.

The restaurant also accepts credit cards from the common providers as a means of payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.