Images
ContributeNo images to show
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute FeedbackAmerican Bluestone offers a mixed experience that leaves diners divided. While the brisket and chicken disappoint with lack of flavor and poor texture, standout items like chili cheese fries and cornbread receive praise. Fast service and a welcoming atmosphere enhance the dining experience, yet some found the portions misleading for the price. Guests appreciate the smoky, juicy meats, craving more balanced sides, while dessert options seem standard for casual dining. Overall, American Bluestone has potential but could benefit from refining its menu and quality to truly satisfy Melbourne's barbecue enthusiasts.
In terms of barbecue restaurants in Melbourne, this was definitely one of the worst we have tried. The brisket, which they claimed was double smoked, lacked any smoke ring or bark and came already covered in sauce, which is never a good sign. The meat was fatty and chewy, lacking flavor. The chicken looked crispy but had no taste, and the mac and cheese, which was actually croquettes, were dry and lacked cheese sauce. The cornbread was the only decent item as the butter had soaked in, but the rest was dense and flavorless. Desserts were mediocre, with standard pre-made cake slices that one might expect at a cheap Italian restaurant chain. The only positives were the incredibly fast service (our food arrived within 10 minutes of ordering) and the friendly, efficient servers. The chili cheese fries were also a standout. We had high hopes after the appetizers, but unfortunately, the quality of the meal went downhill from there. For a bill of $165 for a deer dish, 2 sides, 3 meats, and dessert, we did not feel the value was there. With so many other barbecue options in Melbourne, we were surprised that this place is still in operation and now question the validity of their 5-star reviews.
Upon entering, one is immediately greeted warmly. There is no rush to place an order, allowing time to peruse the menu. The American BBQ cuisine is top-notch, with perfectly cooked and juicy meat. The sides, particularly the cornbread, are also outstanding. The restaurant offers a good selection of beer and American whiskey. Overall, it was a pleasant dining experience and I am excited for my next visit.
Wow. everyone loved it. not complaining, and that says much)
American Bluestone is a restaurant you go to with family and friends to get that friendly service, beautiful meals with a great atmosphere… it’s a great location with ample parking located behind it which makes it perfect considering on a main road, would recommend it to anyone who loves to eat meat
Note of serving size would be handy so as to give you an indication of what you are getting Mac cheese to fancy for me , meats were great chips great , definitely visit again
Full Menu
More information
QR-code link to the menu
