Bella's - Matlacha

Italian, Pizza, Vegetarian Friendly
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Bella's

Bella's
4.6 / 5 (604 reviews)

Menu

Here you will find the menu of Bella's in Matlacha. At the moment, there are 9 menus and drinks on the menu.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Uriah

Images

Bella's Outside Bella's Menu Bella's Food Bella's Outside

Feedback

★ 4.6 / 5 from 604 reviews

Was Ena Schulist at Bella's a mag?
First time ordering pizza this week, absolutely amazing crust and sauce! Best pizza we have had in years. If you love good pizza please try them, you won't be disappointed. Definitely our new go to. View all feedback.

bhackett-3
13.05.2023

The best place to find pure comfort food and friendly staff! If you want a trail to the Vibes of Matlacha, just see how you feel at Bella and you will know how the whole island is. It's great. Your pizza is delicious! Freshly made when you order and boy it is worth waiting. They also try to make new, different flavors, and we were lucky enough to try their attempt at a Mcdonald's big Mac pizza - wow it was good and unlike anything I tried. I am a big fan of this place and would highly recommend if you are in the area!

poberbrunner-1
13.05.2023

I had a delightful visit on Sunday afternoon. The staff was friendly, the food was delicious, and the prices were reasonable, all set in a charming atmosphere. The restaurant is housed in one of the historic buildings in the heart of Matlacha, making it a welcoming spot. It's conveniently located right in the center of the pedestrian area, making it a must-visit when in Matlacha.

bshields-3
13.05.2023

During my day trip to the island, I made a brief stop with my camera at this restaurant. The staff were incredibly friendly, and the food was delicious. They even recommended some great spots to photograph while I explored the island. Here's one of my favorite shots from the day!

uriah95
13.05.2023

We recently tried Bella Pizza at its new location, and it was outstanding! The pizza crust was incredibly fresh, and the cheese blend was absolutely delicious. What a charming spot! Dario, who was on his first day, was excited to welcome us. His father is the pizza maker (Mike, perhaps?), and the pizza was fantastic! We used to be regulars at the old location, and we’re thrilled to see that it’s still the best place for fresh pizza!

xlubowitz-student2
13.05.2023

Wandered in one evening to a friendly and gracious staff. We found the white pizza on the menu! Great crust and very cheesy! Attentive staff (thanks for taking care of our forgotten cell phone until we could get back), cute decor and fun central location. Nice to have delivery as an option next time. Great service!!

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.