Reviews
What Tripadvisor likes about Gregorio's Pizzeria:
Best Italian Food On Long Island Delicious, yummy, superb, beyond belief, palate tummy pleasing. This is a best kept secret. A must try! I had baked ziti w/eggplant parm. The sauce would please all top chefs like it pleased me. I had bread so I could get up all the sauce cheese. Hubby had penne w/broccoli Rabe, sausage in an oil garlic sauce. He's been on the phone since we got home telling all his friends how delici... View all feedback. What Mary B doesn't like about Gregorio's Pizzeria:
Horrible. Ordered meatball parm hero. Bread was soggy and cold. Slice of grandma pie soggy Asked driver to leave on stoop and not to ring doorbell but he did and my dog went crazy. Won’t be ordering from here anymore View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Horrible salad. They give you brown lettuce and rotten tomatoes. It used to be good.
Horrible. Ordered meatball parm hero. Bread was soggy and cold. Slice of grandma pie soggy Asked driver to leave on stoop and not to ring doorbell but he did an...
read moreHorrible!!! Like there food but!!! Tonight’s order went very bad bread tasted like it just came out of freezer. Meatball hero horrible. Bread like bad aftertast...
read moreFood not bad I stopped going there because the place is filthy.
Most amazing pizza. This will be our go to pizza place!