Papeno's Pizza - Marengo
Papeno's Pizza
Menu
On this website, you will find the complete menu of Papeno's Pizza from Marengo. Currently, there are 23 meals and drinks available.
Nestled near Marengo Cave, this small Italian eatery offers a mix of standout dishes and unique charm. Loyal patrons praise its crispy, flavorful pizzas—especially the Meat Lovers and pepperoni-sausage-mushroom varieties—and rave about the burnt garlic bread and hearty pasta, though some find the pasta a bit chewy. The friendly staff and affordable prices add to the appeal, making it a popular spot for casual dining. While the ambiance can be quirky and service occasionally uneven, the bold flavors and character of the place often win over visitors seeking an authentic, unpretentious experience away from typical chain fare.
Images
Feedback
Was Cj Quick at Papeno's Pizza a mag?
**Service:** Dine-in
**Meal Type:** Dinner
**Price per Person:** $10–20
**Food:** 5/5
**Service:** 5/5
**Atmosphere:** 5/5
**Recommended Dishes:** Breadsticks and Meat Lovers Pizza.
What M R dislikes about Papeno's Pizza:
I cannot recommend this pizza place. We recently moved to the area and ordered six pizzas to feed our moving crew. Unfortunately, we only managed to eat a bite of one slice before tossing the rest in the trash. Save your money—just grab a frozen pizza instead; it will taste much better. We won't be returning. View all feedback.
The staff was quite unfriendly. I would rate the food a 4, the service a 2, and the atmosphere a 3.
Love there pizza Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Breadsticks With, Pepperoni Sausage Mushroom Pizza
I was curious about what kind of experience I was stepping into. The woman running the place was quite fiery and kept mentioning how she was ready to quit. Her pizza-cutting skills would put even Michael Myers to shame! It was my first time trying pizza from a trailer, but I learned from "Breaking Bad" not to underestimate a cook in a trailer. I'm not sure if we had sausage or raccoon on our pizza, but it was way better than anything from Papa John's. This spot may lack a bit in the kindness and cleanliness departments, but it definitely has character—and some fantastic pizza. In the end, that's what really counts.
The meat lover's pizza and chef salad were outstanding! They were incredibly flavorful!
I've ordered the same pizza 3 times and it's been wrong everytime. I verified they had it wrote down correctly each time and they still got it wrong. I called them to make a complaint and they wanted me to drive 30 minutes to bring it back. It's rediculous and they don't care rather your satisfied or not Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50
Menu
Salads
Side Dishes
Italian Specialties
Snacks
Pizza Snacks
Salad
More information
QR-Code for the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.3 / 5 (2154 reviews)International Sandwiches AmericanVan's Country Table
Indiana Highway 64 270, 47140 Marengo, US
"Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"
★ 4.4 / 5 (979 reviews)Pubs American Fast Food Burgers FoodMarengo Tavern
South Depot Street 350, 47140 Marengo, US
"Great cave and our guide Katie was great Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"
★ 4.7 / 5 (18 reviews)#17 Pizza in Marengo Steak MeatBuck's Produce, Groceries, And Pizza
154 IN-64, Marengo, Indiana, USA, United States
"Great place for Merkley-Bacon. buck is the best!"