Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute FeedbackThe Oyster Society on Marco Island has received mixed reviews from diners. Some praised the excellent bread service, oyster trio, dragon sushi, and good quality scallops and sea bass. Others found the food average, with high prices and poor service, although appreciating the quiet atmosphere. While some had a great experience with delicious food, ample portions, and exceptional service, others were disappointed with cold meals and average dishes. Overall, the restaurant seems to offer a diverse culinary experience, with standout dishes like Hawaiian ahi, but noise levels could be a drawback for some diners. Reservations are recommended for those seeking a memorable dining experience at The Oyster Society.
Always a wonderful experience!!! Food is delicious and portions are ample !! Service is exceptional and always a welcoming atmosphere!!! Another Marco gem! A must try !
Our baked oysters were so dry and overcooked we ordered some raw instead. We We love them and we’re very disappointed.
We had a wonderful meal with our out of town guests. Meal was well paced. All of the appetizers, salads and entree's were hot and delicious. It was a beautiful night to sit outside and Robina made it a very special evening as always.
Our waiter was excellent and helpful so I typed them well. However, if I looked at food quality in their congratulations, it would have been much less. while eating decent taste, every evening meal was cold. feels more like a chain than a fixed location.
Love the live music! Server seemed a bit too hurried and the sushi wasn’t my favorite have had better in the Midwest which shouldn’t be the case. She crab soup was very good. The complimentary bread was delicious and I enjoyed my potato crusted grouper. Carrot cake was a little disappointing (strong ginger flavor).
Full Menu
Salads
Pasta
Create Your Own Signature Surf & Turf
Snacks To Share
Specialties
Plates
More information
QR-code link to the menu
