Images
ContributeNo images to show
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Sweetteeness likes about Pie Guy Pizza:
Loved it!!!! Reminded me of New York style pizza. Thin, crispy crust with just the right amount of everything. We put leftovers in the oven and they baked up perfectly. We plan to go again. Great neighborhood and it was attached to a great beer pub (name in the photos) that offered small glasses at a great price… we tried a pineapple and a pink guava … both were great ️ View all feedback.
What Meredith B doesn't like about Pie Guy Pizza:
There's no way to order extra sauce when ordering online. Pizza is largely flavorless. Could benefit from some oregano at least. It's fine, probably better when you've been drinking, but for NY style, I vastly prefer Pie Guy. View all feedback.
A proper thin New York slice. Crispy on the bottom and greasy/cheesy on top.
Pizza is amazing, good late night eats, and the lady up front is great at doing her job.
Great pizza, great bar, I'd pay for the free Kool Aid
Excellent… I’m from NJ …worked in and around NYC most of my life … pizza is in my blood from birth…. Been longing for real pizza since moving to the mid west… this place is the real deal! Good people… good vibes… a bar….perfect…
Typically tastes better. Not sure what happened but it just wasn't really good this time around.
More information
QR-code link to the menu
