Everly - Reviews

Dinner was amazing. My husband and I spit the Scandinavian meatballs. Perfect balance of sweet, vinegary and heat. I usually get steak frite buy decided to try... read more Dinner was amazing. My husband and I spit the Scandinavian meatballs. Perfect balance of sweet, vinegary and heat. I usually get steak frite buy decided to try grilled oyster mushrooms. it was serve as if it were a strip steak, but vegetarian. It tasted rich. The fingerlings and peas were just right and the amount just right. Hibiscus limeade was refreshing and good. I had the vanilla sundae with match crumble and hot fudge. Don't be put off by the greenish color from the matcha, it's a sprinkle of crunch on a hot fudge sundae. So good. finally, our server was great. perfect timing. Took time to explain different things when I asked. For as high end as this dinner felt it was a good price. Highly recommend.

Wonderful brunch at Everly. Highly recommend you get this on your list for 2023. The food and service are always top notch at Food Fight Restaurants. read more Wonderful brunch at Everly. Highly recommend you get this on your list for 2023. The food and service are always top notch at Food Fight Restaurants.

Visited Everly for a date night recently. The staff and atmosphere were really great. Service was also very quick even though the restaurant was busy. I would h... read more Visited Everly for a date night recently. The staff and atmosphere were really great. Service was also very quick even though the restaurant was busy. I would highly recommend the meatball appetizer— so tasty! We also had the kimchi and carrot appetizer which we enjoyed. I had a latte which was delicious. The entrees themselves were good. The food was plated beautifully.

Our brunch was beautiful! Everly has a great ambiance and very good food service. read more Our brunch was beautiful! Everly has a great ambiance and very good food service.

Excellent service in a fun night out. Our server was attentive but not intrusive. She gave wonderful info to help us make our drink and eats choices. Everly nev... read more Excellent service in a fun night out. Our server was attentive but not intrusive. She gave wonderful info to help us make our drink and eats choices. Everly never disappoints.

My daughter's and grandkids favorite place when we meet in Madison. Lots of vegetarian and vegan choices with great flavors read more My daughter's and grandkids favorite place when we meet in Madison. Lots of vegetarian and vegan choices with great flavors

The food at this restaurant is fantastic, and I really appreciate the variety of vegan options available. The service was outstanding, and our server was excell... read more The food at this restaurant is fantastic, and I really appreciate the variety of vegan options available. The service was outstanding, and our server was excellent! I also enjoy the drinks offered here. They cater to various dietary needs, including vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options.

I really enjoyed my experience at Everly; the atmosphere is bright and inviting! We were welcomed immediately and the service was excellent. I ordered the Butte... read more I really enjoyed my experience at Everly; the atmosphere is bright and inviting! We were welcomed immediately and the service was excellent. I ordered the Butternut Squash curry, but I’m not sure if the chef was just a bit heavy-handed with the spices that day or if that's the usual recipe. It wasn’t spicy heat, just overly strong, which overshadowed the other flavors in the dish. I wouldn’t order it again. My son had the honey chicken sandwich, which he really liked. Our other guest tried the cubano and said it was quite good. For dessert, we shared the bananas foster, but it didn’t live up to its name at all. We all regretted not choosing something else. The puff pastry didn’t complement the dish well and had an unusual flavor that didn’t quite fit. Of course, taste is subjective, and it might just be that I didn’t connect with what they're trying to achieve. I’ll definitely return to try other items and see if I simply chose the wrong dishes for my taste that day.

The ambiance is warm and refined, with flourishing indoor plants that add to the charm. Everly is perfect for anything from a quick lunch to a complete dinner w... read more The ambiance is warm and refined, with flourishing indoor plants that add to the charm. Everly is perfect for anything from a quick lunch to a complete dinner with dessert. Over the years, we have never left disappointed after a meal at Everly.

Stopped here for Brunch on a Sunday. Atmosphere is very light and bright and we were seated right away, which was great. The server came by promptly and took bo... read more Stopped here for Brunch on a Sunday. Atmosphere is very light and bright and we were seated right away, which was great. The server came by promptly and took both our food and drink order right way. Our drinks came quickly but the food took far too long and when it arrived it was warm, not hot. I ordered the vegan veggie scramble (with tofu) which was supposed to have seasonal vegetables in it. The only vegetables I could see were 5 half slices of cherry tomato, and a few shavings of what could have been asparagus? That was it for a veggie scramble. I was expecting onion, mushroom, zucchini, broccoli or something more. So it was pretty much a giant plate of seasoned tofu for $14. Pretty disappointing.