Eagle Crest - Madison

Dive, Burgers, Cheese
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Eagle Crest

Eagle Crest
3.8 / 5 (533 reviews)

Description

Nestled in a cozy bar atmosphere, this restaurant offers a mix of delightful flavors and hit-or-miss experiences. Diners rave about the mouthwatering burgers, generous portions, and reasonable prices, making it a contender for comfort food. However, inconsistent service, particularly during peak hours with limited staffing, can lead to frustrating delays and mistakes in orders. While some patrons enjoy their meals and the nostalgic vibe, others recount unsatisfactory encounters marked by poor customer service and unappetizing dishes. A mixed bag, this restaurant shows potential for great value but challenges in execution that diners should consider.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Roland

Feedback

★ 3.8 / 5 from 533 reviews
kristoffer-daugherty
29.08.2022

This visit was an improvement from my previous experiences. The service was a bit slow due to being short-staffed, but it was not a major issue. I will definitely be returning.

fschaden-chef7
29.08.2022

The dining experience was absolutely terrible. Despite hearing rave reviews about this place for the past 5 years, we were very disappointed when we finally tried it. The waitress also served as the cook and bartender, and the menu only offered sandwiches. We ordered a well-done hamburger for $9.00, which was served with a pickle and a few pieces on a hard Texas toast. The bacon was overcooked and inedible. The only positive aspect was that the Pabst Blue Ribbon and Miller Lite were cold. After a $35.00 tab and a box of uneaten leftovers, we had a very bad overall experience.

nadia-cronin
29.08.2022

I have been to this restaurant twice – once for Taco Tuesday and once for Sunday breakfast. I had a very positive experience both times with the food and the staff.

roland-skip-kraiss
04.03.2024

The new owner is making positive changes at the restaurant. If you haven't visited in a while, it's worth checking out!

barb-and-randy-jurew
04.03.2024

The breakfast at this restaurant is fantastic, with huge portions. I had a great lunch there a few weeks ago as well.

Menu

  • Sandwiches

    Tenderloin Steak (6 Oz. Sandwich
    Tenderloin Steak (6 Oz. Sandwich
    $9.3
    Ham Sandwich Hot
    Ham Sandwich Hot
    $7.8
    Blt On Texas Toast Sandwich
    Blt On Texas Toast Sandwich
    $8.3
  • Deluxe Burgers

    Cheeseburger With Ham
    Cheeseburger With Ham
    $9.8
  • Starters

    Eagle Burger
    Eagle Burger
    $7.5
  • Hamburgers

    Cheeseburger With Egg
    Cheeseburger With Egg
    $8.8

FAQ

The restaurant offers the opportunity to experience sporting events on a TV / screen.

The restaurant also accepts credit cards from the common providers for payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.