Bottle Hill Tavern - Feedback

Some of the best food I have? ve had in a tavern! Definitely order the crabs waffles fries because the white Cheddar sauce that comes with it is so addictive. T...

A reasonably priced Restaurant with big portions. Great atmosphere, indoors and out.Variety of liquor and beers options to choose from. Menu is not too big, wit...

This is our favorite local spot here in Madison to enjoy their happy hour and a cocktail or great beer. We love the place so much we had our wedding reception h...

3 1/2 stars The 2022 culinary adventures got off to an uneven start. My intrepid chums and I decided to visit Bottle Hill for a post First of the Year hike lunc...

We've been here for more than two years to pamper meals. we tried Thanksgiving somewhere else today and the food was so bad that we didn't eat it and come back!...

Today I think I'm the happiest man in Madison, NJ! Today was the opening of Bottle Hill Tavern! It opened at 11 a.m., and I soon joined at 11:05 a.m. Two boys w...

Great place to relax, have a beer and some great dishes. Marty Horn knows how to make it. He sprinkled the menu with some old Pals Cabin Favorites. Mushroom sou...

Today with hubby! Chicken wings were perfect! Crab cake was mostly crab, delicious. Definitely want to go back and try the turkey. Expects the house dressing to...

We had burgers and sweet potatories. Delicious and cooked to perfection place looks beautiful! The prices are also great!

The soft opening last night was fantastic!! The food was fabulous, atmosphere awesome! Can’t wait to go back!!

Lovely night sitting outside with friends. The menu had many choices for every palate. The fried shrimp appetizer was delicious and nice size shrimp. The entree...

We have been coming here now for over two years for holiday meals (ps- they have these meals every day! … we tried somewhere else today for Thanksgiving and the...

This is a great spot in Madison. Definitely recommend trying it out. There are a few downsides: 1. They don't take reservations and they are very busy. You usua...

So we are 4 and got seated fast, it was Saturday so pretty busy. Drinks came quick then our server disappeared . He finally came back and we ordered food for mo...

Great little spot, good and interesting food. Friendly service even during busy lunch rush. Price point at lunch is GREAT. Only complaint is that it can get lou...

The food and service at this restaurant are excellent. The location is fantastic, but it can be a bit noisy, making it difficult to hear conversations with your...

The only positive aspect of this restaurant is its convenient location. Unfortunately, the service was subpar and the food was dreadful. I ordered the turkey sa...

Really good lunch, efficient service. The Shrimp Po' Boy was crunchy and delicious, very fresh shrimp. We loved the Deviled Eggs too, good flavors. Definitely w...

We called in advance to reserve a table for our group of 10, which included a person in a wheelchair. When we arrived, I was surprised by how narrow the table w...

Regularly support this establishment and tonight attempted to order take out. Was hung up on by a male manager . I was told that they had 20 tickets and their k...

We arrived on a Friday night and had to only wait 20 minutes. You can make a reservation for 6 plus but have to wait if it’s a smaller group. Kid-friendliness:...

The food was good but the waiter was not kind and made comments about the amount of food I chose to eat Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10...

The food was average. 35 minutes on a Sunday afternoon to get 3 sandwiches dumped down on our table, I was bored of looking at the bare brick wall. Won’t be goi...

Gorgeous day to have a quick lunch here at Bottle Hill Tavern in Madison. I love Madison for its city feel, nice restaurants, train station and shopping! Loved...

Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5