Tony Boloney's - Long Branch
Menu
The menu of Tony Boloney's from Long Branch comprises about 85 different menus and drinks. On average you pay about $19.4 for a dish / drink.
This restaurant invites a range of opinions, highlighting both culinary delights and service woes. While some diners praise the quality of certain dishes, like the pizza and custom subs, others express frustration over unfulfilled orders and incorrect items. Complaints about poor service and high prices prevail, with many citing a lack of accountability from staff when issues arise. Although some consistently enjoyed the flavors, others lament the inconsistent quality, particularly regarding wings and sauces. Ultimately, this establishment may appeal to those willing to navigate its ups and downs for a potentially rewarding meal.
Feedback
Was Shayne D at Tony Boloney's a mag?
The food was tasty, but I was disappointed to receive the Pope Leo pizza without the pesto sauce that was advertised. Also, my side of vodka sauce for the garlic knots turned out to be marinara instead. The garlic knots were not as garlic-infused as shown in the picture. Overall, the meal was delicious, but it did not meet my expectations. The prices were on the higher side, considering the discrepancies between the... View all feedback.
What User dislikes about Tony Boloney's:
I understand that it was busy for Labor Day and the staff might have felt overwhelmed, but there’s no reason to be rude to customers. There was a sign indicating they would be closed until 4:30, and I just wanted to ask a question about ordering a Taco Pie, knowing it takes some time to prepare. Instead, I was essentially asked to leave and told they were closed until 4:30. Afterwards, I placed an order through the a... View all feedback.
Our experience at this restaurant was not good. Several dashers dropped off while waiting for our order, but we were prepared for the 70-minute estimated delivery time. I ordered 3 subs and 2 sides, and after nearly an hour, a fourth dasher finally started the delivery process. The food arrived within 15 minutes, but I was disappointed by the quality. The price was high at $16 per 10-inch sub, but the subs were lacking in filling and flavor, with a lot of grease. My husband had been wanting to try this place for a while, but our experience on Father's Day was very disappointing. The chicken wings were the only redeeming dish, as everything else arrived ice cold. I will not be ordering from this restaurant again.
Built my own sub and they nailed it. Will definitely be ordering from here again. Large sandwiches and high quality, you pay for what you get and it's worth it here.
The food was tasty, but I was disappointed to receive the Pope Leo pizza without the pesto sauce that was advertised. Also, my side of vodka sauce for the garlic knots turned out to be marinara instead. The garlic knots were not as garlic-infused as shown in the picture. Overall, the meal was delicious, but it did not meet my expectations. The prices were on the higher side, considering the discrepancies between the advertised and actual food items.
Don't buy a wrap, half the food same price though.
The restaurant consistently forgets to include the extra sauce that you have to pay for on the side.
Full Menu
Slices
Swine Fighter-Slice$9.1 Cluck, Oink, Mmm$5.0 Shogun Shadowboxer Slice$5.0 I Will Fuckin' Smash You-Slice$7.1 Roll Up Tha Broccoli-Slice$5.012" Pies
Roll Up Tha Broccoli$19.2
More information
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.6 / 5 (8590 reviews)Vegetarian Italian Coffee Fish PastaTrama's Trattoria
115 Brighton Ave Long Branch, NJ 07740, 07740-5336, United States
★ 4.3 / 5 (1284 reviews)Vegetarian Pizza Sicilian PizzeriaBella Pizzeria
425 Liberty St. Long Branch, NJ 07740, United States
★ 4.3 / 5 (1270 reviews)Pizza Vegetarian Pizzeria ItalianNunzio's Pizzeria
230 Westwood Ave, Long Branch, United States