Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What J T likes about Newburgh Station Pizzeria:
Super delicious! First-timer here. Very easy to order over the phone and pickup curbside. Got a gluten-free cheese bread for our kid and a dill pickle cheese bread for us. Both were very good. Can?t wait to try their other items!! View all feedback.
What Melanie Knight doesn't like about Newburgh Station Pizzeria:
Unsatisfactory food. The Philly sub was over cooked or just dry had no sauce on it. (Mayo) The Michigan chicken wrap was 75% lettuce. They got the order wrong on the calzone. Was supposed to be chicken and pineapple but put bacon on instead. We don?t eat bacon. They are so busy with phone calls no one answers the phone. Food was just not worth the money. View all feedback.
Super delicious! First-timer here. Very easy to order over the phone and pickup curbside. Got a gluten-free cheese bread for our kid and a dill pickle cheese bread for us. Both were very good. Can?t wait to try their other items!!
The employees were friendly and warm and I felt good about being there and giving them my money! I ordered a pickle pizza at the suggestion of the nice lady behind the counter. It was an interesting array of ingredients but they made a delicious combination and I will probably get it again!
I saw this place as I drove by the other day and decided to try it tonight. I wasn't sure what to make of a pickle cheesebread but it turns out, it's fantastic! The calzone is huge and also delicious. As I was waiting for my food, I was looking at the menu and it looks like they have a large menu full of subs, sandwiches and pizza. The owner was inside and running around to fill orders while keeping customers happy and apologizing for a slight delay. I can confirm it was worth the wait and will return again next week as I may have a new favorite pizza place. Support small business!
We order from here at least once a week! Their Toasted Turkey Rueben is divine, breadsticks are amazing and the pepperoni monster pizza is awesome! If you have not tried them yet, you should! ????
Unsatisfactory food. The Philly sub was over cooked or just dry had no sauce on it. (Mayo) The Michigan chicken wrap was 75% lettuce. They got the order wrong on the calzone. Was supposed to be chicken and pineapple but put bacon on instead. We don?t eat bacon. They are so busy with phone calls no one answers the phone. Food was just not worth the money.