Fanatics Pub - Lima

Grilled Sirloin Steak Salad, American, Pub
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +15856242080

Menu

Here you will find the menu of Fanatics Pub in Lima. At the moment, there are 36 dishes and drinks on the list.

Fanatics, a local pub in Lima, NY, offers a lively atmosphere paired with delicious, affordable food, making it a sought-after destination for those looking for a good meal and entertainment. Many patrons rave about the standout mac and cheese selections, while the pub wings receive particular praise. However, experiences can vary; on busy nights, the service may lag, and the noise from patrons can overshadow live performances. Despite these occasional drawbacks, many visitors appreciate the friendly staff and vibrant ambiance, underscoring Fanatics as a fun spot for trivia nights, live music, and tasty dining experiences worth seeking out.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Scott

Images

Fanatics Pub Food Fanatics Pub Food Fanatics Pub Drink Fanatics Pub Drink Fanatics Pub Drink Fanatics Pub Outside Fanatics Pub Inside Fanatics Pub Food

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 1914 reviews

Was Christine Bayer at Fanatics Pub a mag?
We went on a busy Thursday night when there was a band playing, but that didn’t stop the great service. The atmosphere, service, and the food were amazing. We even got a sweet treat on the way out! Recommend this place! View all feedback.

What Casey Cannady dislikes about Fanatics Pub:
A local friend told us about trivia night on Wednesdays, so we thought we'd give it a try. Got seated quickly, but took quite a while to get our drinks and food... to be frank, service was slow. Trivia was fun, but also slow. Was a total of 6 games with 3 questions per game. Was supposed to start at 6:30pm, but started 15-20 minutes late. We ended up leaving at 1/2 time... which was around 8:15pm. I've had a spinal f... View all feedback.

casey-cannady-engine-3
Casey 20.09.2024 - 13:43

A local friend told us about trivia night on Wednesdays, so we thought we'd give it a try. Got seated quickly, but took quite a while to get our drinks and food... to be frank, service was slow. Trivia was fun, but also slow. Was a total of 6 games with 3 questions per game. Was supposed to start at 6:30pm, but started 15-20 minutes late. We ended up leaving at 1/2 time... which was around 8:15pm. I've had a spinal fusion, so my back just can't take most chairs and I just couldn't do another 2 hours at the observed rate. Our food was only OK. Not sure if we came on a bad night, but kind of frustrating to spent $65+ on 2x sandwich entrees, each with fries and a side salad. We also had 2 beers and 1 drink and waters.

joyce-christopher-2
Joyce 20.09.2024 - 13:43

Listened to female song writers on fanatics patio. Good drinks and food

ron-manning-firefigh
Ron 20.09.2024 - 13:43

Good food, fair prices, and always something going on!

scott-fisher-4
Scott 07.03.2025 - 15:01

Very nice hometown Pub to see a great band, Butch Rolle featuring Rusty Fisher. Good food also.

gregory-radford
Gregory 07.03.2025 - 15:01

I was VERY disappointed in the fish fry. The house -cut French Fries were soggy and cool and the fish was not hot. Both my wife and myself were not pleased.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.