Reviews
What Alex Staarmann likes about Nicola's Pizza:
This restaurant offers fantastic New Jersey-style pizza along with outstanding customer service and a delightful ambiance. The prices are very reasonable. The building is likely over 200 years old and has the charm of an old roadside tavern. There’s a cozy wood-burning fireplace in the dining area that adds to the atmosphere. I highly recommend it! View all feedback. What Gabriella Fancello Cappelle doesn't like about Nicola's Pizza:
We had the cheese pizza with Caesar salad and garlic bread. Garlic bread wasn’t very good and salad was okay. The cheese pizza was decent, but nothing special. There are tables to sit in the back and it’s pretty empty. Service was friendly and quick. Would go back for a quick slice of pizza in a pinch. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Great mom and pop place. Parking is a little dicey, but the food is fantastic. Great pizza, great subs, fair prices, and nice staff.
Pizza is done exactly the way I like it !! Thin crust and well done with a nice little crunch. Garlic Knots are EXCELLENT!
Nicola's Pizza in Lamberville offers decent pizza and has a very nice and friendly staff/owner, which is always a plus and made me really want to give this high...
read moreThis place was solid as can be…in a small quaint town Lambertville is, this place could survive well in a big city. The pizza was addictive.
A slice and a soda for a good price, and outdoor seating makes for a nice quick stop for lunch.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read morePizza is terrific, a classic Jersey pizza ! Staff were very courteous and atmosphere was great!
Me and my parents came here alot when I was a kid in the 90s every year during the NJ car show that used to be big that would take up two towns but I haven't be...
read moreWe had the cheese pizza with Caesar salad and garlic bread. Garlic bread wasn’t very good and salad was okay. The cheese pizza was decent, but nothing special....
read moreThe nicoboli fresh at the pizzeria is great. I purchased a case of nicoboli's that were premade frozen par baked they are inconsistent with the filling and quit...
read moreThis place is completely amazing. The building has such history from the 1700s. The owners are so kind and accommodating. The dining room is simple but has a ni...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more