Images
ContributeFeedback
Contribute Feedback What Madalyn Raynor likes about Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop:
The peanut butter cream cake and chocolate chip cakes were excellent. We also had thumbprint cookies, which I really enjoyed. Unlike other bakeries which have a pecan crust, these had a more shortbread-like texture. They were still very tasty. I can't wait to try out other flavors of cake! View all feedback.
What Aisha Lehner doesn't like about Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop:
Indulging in the delicious cakes at Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is definitely worth the splurge. Their selection includes large (9 inch) and small (4 inch) cakes in flavors like key lime, peanut butter, coconut cream, pecan, apple, and the unique I-40. I tried the small chocolate cream pie and apple custard during my visit and was always satisfied with their treats. Perfect for any special occasion or holiday gathering!... View all feedback.
Buttermilk sky has the best cake around! I had the pawn and pumpkin pussies around the celebrations, and for ostern my brother brought the earthly. delicious does not begin to describe these cakes. the crust is just the right combination of crispy, soft and flowing, and the beats are perfect each time. that sounds strange, but I'm even impressed with the packaging. they come into a beautiful, heavy box that cries quality. if you weren't at buttermilk sky, go.
The menu may be limited, but each dish is prepared perfectly. Anyone who enjoys Pecan Pie and chocolate must try the I-40. The coconut dessert was one of the best I've ever had. My top choice is the seasonal strawberry, it's the best I've ever tasted. I will definitely be returning!
We absolutely adore Buttermilk Sky! The wide variety of regular pies and seasonal specials always keep things exciting. The crusts are like nothing I've ever tasted before, but they are incredibly delicious! Don't make the mistake I did and wait too long to try the Buttermilk pie. It was a revelation for me, and absolutely delightful - almost like cheesecake. It's a sweet treat, but not overly so. If you're lucky enough to snag a warm chocolate chip cookie pie fresh from the oven, you're in for a real treat. However, my personal favorite remains the coconut cream pie. The decor is charming, and they have cute trinkets for sale if pie isn't your thing - but really, who doesn't love pie? On one visit, we were delighted to find a fantastic bluegrass trio performing in the store. It was such a fun experience! I can't help but smile every time I step foot in there.
While the menu may be limited, it is for a good reason - all of their desserts are made perfectly every time. If you enjoy pecan pie and chocolate, you must try the I-40. The coconut dessert was outstanding, one of the best I have ever had. My personal favorite is the seasonal strawberry, which is also the best I have ever tasted. I will definitely be returning to this restaurant!
Buttermilk Sky offers the best pies in town! I've tried their pecan and pumpkin pies during the holidays, and most recently my brother brought home their delicious strawberry pie for Easter. These pies are beyond delicious. The crust is perfectly crunchy, soft, and flaky, while the toppings are consistently delectable. Even the packaging is impressive, coming in a beautiful and high-quality box that exudes excellence. If you haven't visited Buttermilk Sky yet, you need to go now!