Rustlers Grill - Kinsley

Should have rode on, I guess they just weren't prepared for 10 people, We read the reviews and it looked like a good stop for lunch, and actually some of the fo... read more Should have rode on, I guess they just weren't prepared for 10 people, We read the reviews and it looked like a good stop for lunch, and actually some of the food was good, however the waitress/bartender (4th day on the job) was totally overwhelmed. Our table got waited on first and we got the right food and pretty quick. The other table suffered wrong food, burnt chicken, extrememly slow (we were there over 2 hours) but the cook was the problem and the poor waitress took the brunt of the complaints. The sad thing was there were people around including the owner who seemed connected with the place that could have lent a hand but did not.

The food and service were excellent! I would certainly come back! read more The food and service were excellent! I would certainly come back!

I visited Rustlers Grill to meet some friends who live nearby, but unfortunately, the service was disappointing. I waited 30 minutes at the bar for another beer... read more I visited Rustlers Grill to meet some friends who live nearby, but unfortunately, the service was disappointing. I waited 30 minutes at the bar for another beer, even though there were fewer than ten people there. On top of that, the restroom was in poor condition. When we finally caught the attention of the waitress with long curly hair after the long wait, she seemed dismissive. I would recommend choosing either the road to the left or Dodge City instead.

Cold beer and good service, nice place. read more Cold beer and good service, nice place.

We ordered chicken strips and a loaded baked potato. I've had plenty of good potatoes before, but Rustlers Grill absolutely nailed it! The potato was perfectly... read more We ordered chicken strips and a loaded baked potato. I've had plenty of good potatoes before, but Rustlers Grill absolutely nailed it! The potato was perfectly baked and generously topped with butter, sour cream, and bacon. Every bite was pure bliss. I’ll never bother making one at home again—I’ll just come here for it. My husband devoured the chicken and said it was as good as my homemade version. Honestly, I think he preferred it but didn’t want to admit it since I have culinary training. I tried it and actually liked it better than my own. Definitely worth twice the price. Can’t wait to go back on payday for another round. Loved it! 7 out of 5 stars!