Penny's Pizza Pasta - Kīhei

Very cool spot in pleasant setting. We had a great view of the ocean and the pizza felt very authentic. It had amazing flavour. I would only suggest they go a little easier on the quantity of cheese. Only my opinion though. We thoroughly enjoyed ourselves! We will be back ????

From our home in Maple Bay, Vancouver Island, British Columbia CANADA to Maui. We love Penny 's Pizza and Pasta in Kihei, Maui. Chicken Parm is huge and so moist and tasty. We returned for Pizza in Penny 's outdoor Pizza Oven the following night. Outdoor seating on the Lanai. Staff super friendly! Ree (we called her Penny but she 's not the real Penny) was terrific! She was our server. Fun and great, friendly customer service. Aloha and Mahalo.

Great pizza, dough is fluffy yet hardy, sweat tomato sauce and fair portion of toppings. Crew is all really aloha and checked in on us multiple times, even different people. Ocean views from some tables, open air seating, maybe some indoors. Great place all around, looking forward to trying their pasta next!

No complaints here about the service which was great), but we ordered 2-pizzas $25 each) and mine came out with the majority of the crust burnt to a crisp. Had it looked like the pizza my wife received, it would have been really nice. However, there's no way I would have sent that out to a customer. I cut all the crust off and threw the leftovers in the air-fryer for lunch today and it was great. I really like the crust on a pizza though. Anyway, the place seems really nice and again, the service was great. I'd still recommend others to check it out, but send the pizza back if it's burnt.

This is MUCH MORE than a pizza place! We didn't expect much from an Italian restaurant in Maui, but it was absolutely fantastic. We ordered the Caprese Salad, the Bruschetta, the garlic cheese bread, the baked rigatoni and chicken parmesan. Everything was beautifully plated and really tasty. We will return here every time we are visiting Maui.