Yellowfin Kitchen - Key West

American, Kitchen, Catering
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Yellowfin Kitchen

Yellowfin Kitchen
4.2 / 5 (1114 reviews)

Description

Dining at this restaurant presents a blend of exceptional moments and frustrating experiences. While many patrons rave about exquisite dishes, attentive service, and charming ambiance, some diners report oversalted meals, slow service, and unexpected gratuity charges. Winners include vibrant wine dinners with local ingredients and a talented chef creating delightful seafood specialties. Guests appreciate the inviting setting, complete with stunning marina views and poolside offerings. However, vigilance is advised regarding bills, as automatic tips may not be clearly communicated. Overall, the restaurant shines on occasion, yet leave room for improvement in consistency and service transparency.

Last update: 29.01.2026 from: Tim

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 1114 reviews
pavel-wee
06.03.2024

I recently had lunch at a restaurant and wanted to share my thoughts on the experience. The meal was delightful, with a price range of $30 to $50 per person, which I found to be reasonable considering the quality of the food. The ambiance was inviting, and the service was attentive. Overall, it was a pleasant dining experience that I would recommend to others.

nisha
06.03.2024

Great fish and shrimp tacos! Average chicken burger. Overpriced food. Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4

sierra-belote
06.03.2024

The restaurant boasts a fantastic location with views of the marina and resort. The food is excellent, though it comes at a high cost. However, the service leaves something to be desired. As for accessibility, the restaurant is easy to enter, but there is a long ramp that may require assistance if you're navigating it on your own. Overall, I dined in for lunch.

tim-swiat-2
06.03.2024

We have enjoyed breakfast here at the Yellowfin twice. Andrei and Jean were more than attentive and professional making sure that our visit was five stars. While we are still getting used to slowing down from our fast-paced experiences back at home, Andrei was there when we needed him....checking in at the right times and not when we had bites in our mouths. That speaks to someone who understands service. Tremendous time at the resort, and will be back again soon.

sonya-s-mushroom02
06.03.2024

I recently stayed at the OceansEdge resort and dined at the Yellowfin twice. The service from Branka and Alex was outstanding! I really appreciate the option to choose between indoor and outdoor seating, especially with the added charm of live music and fire pits outside. Overall, I would rate the food a perfect 5, the service a 5, and the atmosphere also a 5.

FAQ

The restaurant offers complimentary WiFi for its guests.

You can watch major sporting events on a screen / TV right in the joint.

The rooms on site are wheelchair accessible and can also be used with a wheelchair or physiological disabilities.

The restaurant accepts the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.