Wicked Lick - Key West

#16 - Vegetarian - Key West, American, Ice Cream

Wicked Lick

Wicked Lick
4.5 / 5 (2041 reviews)

Description

Located in the bustling heart of Key West, Wicked Lick has become a popular destination for ice cream lovers, especially those seeking vegan options. While some may consider the prices a bit steep, they align with the overall costs in the area. The ice cream is exceptionally creamy, with unique flavors like dairy-free coconut vanilla bean, pistachio, and cookie butter caramel delighting patrons. Enthusiastic reviews highlight the quality and freshness of the offerings, making Wicked Lick a must-visit for dessert after a day of exploration on Duval. Just remember to walk or Uber, as parking can be a challenge!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Ashley

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 2041 reviews
ashley-tim-glita
31.08.2025

We loved Wicked Lick so much, we went three days in a row while visiting Key West! The ice cream is fantastic—my girls couldn’t get enough of the one scoop with the waffle cone nacho chips (such a fun and tasty twist). The service made it even better—the ladies behind the counter were personal, friendly, and so warm every time we came in. It’s rare to find a spot that hits both the flavor and the experience this well. We’ll definitely be back next year!

junkyard-pirate-squi
31.08.2025

Good coffee and ice cream. Highly recommend the key lime ice cream on the sugar waffle.

lucie
04.11.2023

Really good ice cream! Unfortunately, the staff were quite unfriendly on our visit today. Gave me the wrong ice cream and was very reluctant to change it. Not what you’d expect when you pay so much for 5 ice creams!

beth-hall-school8115
31.08.2025

Great service, server helped with things to see and do in Key West. I purchased an iced white chocolate latte it was fabulous.

je1058
04.11.2023

After spending time walking in the hot sun we stopped in here for a scoop of ice cream… the positive is that they make their own ice creams and they have some fun, unique flavors. The only negative was that they don’t serve/sell a single scoop – Doesn’t make any sense, as every other place does and being mildly lactose intolerant, I prefer to limit my ice cream intake, especially on a very hot day. They do let you try before you buy and they have a decent size selection to choose from. The flavors we tried were awesome! Highly recommend stopping in. Oh, one more negative is they only have chocolate sauce, not hot fudge to go on top. They would totally get 5 stars if it wasn’t for this and the lack of selling a single scoop.

FAQ

A little farther away is Old Town Trolley - Stop 5, where you can also access the public transportation.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.