Reviews
What Chris V doesn't like about Anderson's Frozen Custard:
I had the salted Carmel with almond hard ice cream. It was ok and pretty bland compared to other ice cream shops that make their own. Not enough Carmel. I should have stuck with a soft ice cream twist. View all feedback. What Dee Dee likes about Anderson's Frozen Custard:
Set up with garage doors, lots of desserts to pick from in freezer good food and drinks. My only complaint is you have to go through 3 doors to get to the bathroom so it’s not handicapped friendly. One stall per gender View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Good, but too expensive. I would eat more here, but if I leave, I feel like I could go somewhere else, that was cheaper with the better quality beef. The Bratbe...
read moreDear Andersons. Another Buffalo tradition that should not be passed on. Really good Roast Beef and a wide selection of ice cream and other frozen desserts.
Anderson’s has a particularly creamy and tasty custard with a rather pleasant texture. Combine that with the fact that they use real cream, and our turtle Sunda...
read moreVisited 9/2021. If you love frozen custard then this is the place for you! They have a huge selection of ice cream treats, lemon ice, milk shakes and ice cream...
read moreAlways top notch! As a vegetarian, I LOVE the veggie burgers. And let's be honest who doesn't live that frozen custard? Yum!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreAnderson's Frozen Custard, a beloved staple in Buffalo, offers a blend of delicious food and renowned frozen treats. Guests rave about the hearty roast beef sandwiches, flavorful burgers, and generous portions of fries and frozen custard. While many enjoy the large selection of ice cream and the nostalgic atmosphere, some have expressed concerns over rising prices and inconsistent service, including portion sizes. Despite a few service hitches, the warm and inviting environment continues to draw in crowds eager to savor a classic Buffalo experience, with lines often forming for their signature soft-serve custard.
The food at this restaurant is delicious, but it is on the pricey side. The service is quick for takeout orders. I had dinner here and spent between $10-20 per...
read moreI used to think Anderson's was great. The flavor of the ice cream just isn't that good I'm also disappointed with the sub par service and inconsistent portions....
read moreGreat Roast Beef..and amazing ice cream and super friendly staff
The rare beef on weck at Carl's is fantastic - it's his favorite and mine too!
A great place for ice cream and roast beef sandwiches.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreGreat ice cream and custard! Very good food as well. Roast Beef sandwiches are highlight recommended.
Used to really love it there, but the prices are going through the roof for the seniors like ourselves.Still a nice summertime stop.
Best ice cream I've had. The cinnamon milk shake is my favorite
Great food and service. Lots of ice cream flavors to enjoy. I love coming here!
We love coming here for shakes and onion rings. One of our favorite spots for diner style food.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more