The Pizza Crew from Jerseyville Menu

Patrons of a local pizzeria have had a varied experience, ranging from culinary triumphs to disappointing missteps. While some diners relished the crispy, fresh pizzas, delectable salads, and flavorful wings—often praising the staff's hard work—others found their meals plagued by overcooked pizzas, insufficient cheese, and cold appetizers. Despite inconsistencies in food quality and service timings, particularly during busy nights, many still appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and reasonable prices. These diverse reviews suggest that while the restaurant shows promise, maintaining consistency will be crucial for building a loyal customer base.

Last update: 10.02.2025

Images

Contribute

Images

Reserve now

Reserve a table

Feedback

Contribute Feedback

What User likes about The Pizza Crew:
Not the most pleasant experience at first but ended with fantastic customer service and great food by Steve. In the end he made a mix up and long wait worth the while. Pizza, wings, and salad have been great all times we've ordered. View all feedback.

What User doesn't like about The Pizza Crew:
I was so looking forward to trying the pizza but ended up disappointed. Both pizzas were over cooked, ordered extra cheese on both but there was hardly any cheese on them. Mozzarella sticks and toasted ravs were cold. Took a long time for the order to be ready minutes past the time they said. Bummed. View all feedback.

I was really looking forward to trying the pizza, but ended up being let down. Both pizzas were overcooked and had very little cheese, despite ordering extra. The mozzarella sticks and roasted rolls were cold. It also took a long time for our order to be finished, 15 minutes after the estimated time.

We tried this restaurant for the first time yesterday. I ordered a 16-inch pizza with my choice of toppings, which was super crispy and delicious. The sauce was great and the vegetables were very fresh. The salad and buffalo wings were also fantastic. The staff working there were very friendly and worked extremely hard, especially when they were busy. It was refreshing to see young people who are not afraid to work hard. We will definitely support this local business again!

The pizza was fantastic, but the boneless chicken bites were very tough and overcooked. You can see a photo of them in the comments, if possible.

Wouldn’t answer the phone called multiple times I just wanted to try them out

We’ve eaten here 4 times so far. The first couple times the pizza was awesome. However, the last two times we’ve ordered the pizza is floppy and just lightly cooked. I even asked for well done the last time and it was less cooked the the last time. Definitely a bummer because we thought this would be our new go to pizza spot.

Feedback