Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Amanda C likes about Three Guys From Italy:
Three Guys from Italy is a great place to get a slice of pizza in Journal Square. The restaurant is clean and bright, with a section for seating. There are multiple cases of pizza to choose from, so you're sure to find something you like. Some of the pizzas are saltier than others depending on the topping you get., The crust is on the puffier side, so fair warning to those who like super thin crusts. Overall, Three G... View all feedback.
What John-Paul Georgieff doesn't like about Three Guys From Italy:
This place used to have great pizza especially way back in the day when they were located inside the PATH terminal. I think the business was sold a few times since and the quality has taken a nosedive. Honestly, it's not even average or mediocre, it's awful. Just had two slices one was super thick and chewy where as the other was thinner and crunchy. I could understand the consistency being a little off between visit... View all feedback.
The original cheese pizza was incredible, and the Fettuccine Alfredo was fantastic!
The Original Cheese Pie was terrible. I wish I could share a photo with you. It was hard, lacked cheese, and had too little sauce. Plus, it was cold—either because it was reheated from yesterday's pizza or the driver didn’t bother with a pizza carrier. I can only give it one star for providing seasonings, napkins, and plates.
I had the chicken parmesan and penne, and I must say the chicken parmesan was excellent. However, the sauce on the penne was quite bland and definitely different from the delicious sauce on the chicken parmesan.
You guys are just WOW! Cheese pizza has no competitor! Keep it up Best in JSQ
This pie is absolutely amazing! To put it simply, it was fantastic. The owner was on-site making the pies and truly knows how to run a business the right way. If you're in the area, be sure to stop by for a great New York-style or Sicilian-style pie – you won’t be disappointed, I promise. Parking is convenient too, with a garage right next door.
Full Menu
Salads
Soups
Seafood Dishes
Pizza
This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
More information
QR-code link to the menu
