Heartbreak - Jefferson

American, Burgers, Desserts
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Heartbreak

Heartbreak
4.6 / 5 (795 reviews)

Menu

Here you will find the menu of Heartbreak in Jefferson. At the moment, there are 35 dishes and drinks on the list.

Heartbreak Hotel in Jefferson, NY is an American restaurant with an average rating of 4.2 stars. Operating hours are from 12:00 PM to 11:59 PM this week. For reservations or to check how busy the restaurant is, call (607) 652-7344. They are known for their great cocktails. If you're looking for other options with similar menus, check out Mill Pond Inn. Enjoy your favorite dish at Heartbreak Hotel and don't forget to leave a review!.

Last update: 22.01.2026 from: Jeremy

Images

Heartbreak Menu Heartbreak Menu Heartbreak Food Heartbreak Food Heartbreak Food Heartbreak Food Heartbreak Outside Heartbreak Menu

Feedback

★ 4.6 / 5 from 795 reviews

Was Ray Wood at Heartbreak a mag?
Food was great. I had a Utica club draft...which was served at 30 degrees. IOW perfect. We ate there at around 5 on a friday...lots of families with kids. Which was interesting given the colorful and loud political/current events debate at bar between two of the local gentry. I am not in the area much...but when I am I will stop at the hh. Price per person: $20–30 Food: 4 View all feedback.

What Luigi G dislikes about Heartbreak:
I had the worst steak experience of my life at this restaurant! Although I ordered my steak medium rare, the quality of the meat was simply awful. Even the steak knife struggled to cut through it. My friend and I both ordered ribeyes, and unfortunately, they were both disappointing! View all feedback.

luigi-g-lawyer3
02.10.2024

I had the worst steak experience of my life at this restaurant! Although I ordered my steak medium rare, the quality of the meat was simply awful. Even the steak knife struggled to cut through it. My friend and I both ordered ribeyes, and unfortunately, they were both disappointing!

dawson-falcone
02.10.2024

This restaurant is simply fantastic. I really appreciate the warm and inviting atmosphere, which feels more like a family gathering than a formal dining experience. The food is outstanding, especially the NY strip steak—I’ve ordered it over five times during various visits, and each time it was cooked to perfection. I've often felt compelled to commend the chefs for their work. The service is top-notch, and the staff go out of their way to make you feel at home. If you enjoy great service along with amazing food, this is the place you absolutely must visit—your life won't feel complete without it!

rob-bingle
02.10.2024

Sadie is exceptional behind the bar. By my third visit, she already knew my drink and had it ready for me as soon as I sat down. That's a remarkable quality for a bartender to possess. The regulars are all unique characters; even the most imaginative writers couldn't dream them up. This is one of the top five bars I've ever experienced during my travels. I highly recommend it to anyone with discerning taste who is open to an experience that might be a bit different from what you expect. Great times await!

jeremy-alfano-cactus-3
05.03.2025

The perfect hole in the wall place if you’re in the area. Dive bar atmosphere with plenty of options to eat and drink. The prime rib dinner on the weekends is out of this world. Probably the best I’ve ever had; cooked perfectly with seasoning that blew me away. The mashed potatoes and asparagus sides both were phenomenal. Friendly waitresses too. Great place to hang out. Food: 5

luigi-g-forest71
05.03.2025

The worst steak I have ever had at a restaurant! The steak was cooked medium rare like I asked but the quality of meat was horrible! The steak knife had a hard time cutting through the steak. Me my buddy ordered ribeyes both if them were terrible!!! Price per person: $50–100 Food: 1 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 3

  • Snacks And Sides

  • Meals

    Pretzel M Fresh Chips
    Pretzel M Fresh Chips
    Pork Oss Buco
    Pork Oss Buco
    Bee Tips Mushroom Onion Over Rice
    Bee Tips Mushroom Onion Over Rice
  • Stone Arch Specialties

    Pumpkin Spice Ale
    Pumpkin Spice Ale
  • Traditional Pizza

    Miller Time
    Miller Time

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.