Subway - Jay

Wraps, Salads, Delivery Services
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Subway

Subway
3.4 / 5 (140 reviews)

Menu

On this Site, you will find the comprehensive menu of Subway from Jay. Currently there are 70 meals and beverages available.

**A Mixed Bag at Local Eatery: Consistent Issues and Rare Gems** Dining experiences at this local restaurant are decidedly uneven, with many patrons citing recurring order inaccuracies and inattentive service. Complaints about long drive-thru wait times and employees lacking motivation are common, suggesting inefficiencies in staffing or training. Additionally, instances of charging for basic items like a cup of ice water raise eyebrows about management practices. However, there are glimpses of hope, as some customers report exceptional service and delicious sandwiches when attended by certain staff members. For those seeking a more reliable dining experience, alternate locations may be a better choice.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Lynn

Images

Subway Food Subway Food Subway Food Subway Inside Subway Inside Subway Food Subway Food Subway Drink

Feedback

★ 3.4 / 5 from 140 reviews

Was Summer Record at Subway a mag?
9/10 great experience. Manager reached out to make right with an order. Feels good knowing some people continue to take pride in their work. Will definitely continue to dine here. View all feedback.

What Jen Smith dislikes about Subway:
Always a bad experience! I can’t say that they have been successful at getting my order correct a single time. One time they told me that “they don’t have kids meals”. Today, I made an online order-tuna sandwich with lettuce and tomato. Didn’t get tomatoes. The only thing I am impressed with is how good they are at always messing up the order. I never take time to leave reviews but the experience I have every time th... View all feedback.

soundwave613
22.06.2024

The young employee at the restaurant didn’t seem motivated to work. He was huffing and overall quite grumpy. Additionally, the sandwiches came with barely any toppings.

jessica-gerry
22.06.2024

As many have pointed out, the drive-thru wait time is excessive, likely because they rarely have more than one employee working at a time. I've visited this location multiple times a week due to the lack of alternatives other than McDonald's, and I've never once received a single napkin with my order. This makes me wonder if management is being excessively frugal or if the staff simply lacks the training or common sense to include napkins. On one occasion, my child requested a cup of ice water with their meal and we were charged nearly $5 for it. The employee even kept my receipt, so I'm not sure if that's standard practice or just another instance of poor management. If you're in the area, I recommend making the trip to the Farmington or Turner locations instead. They are definitely worth it.

r-marcoux-student8
22.06.2024

Always a clean friendly environment but always order to go.

lynn-gagnon
22.06.2024

There is never any bread and they don’t make any sandwiches right. And then defend making it wrong. I’m so glad putting bacon on someone’s sandwich who didn’t want it have to have it. The point of ordering ahead is so you don’t have to watch them make it.

mark-glaser-flower56
22.06.2024

Subway in Jay is the best around. Super clean.

Menu

  • Chips

    Lay's Salt And Vinegar
    Lay's Salt And Vinegar
  • Side Dishes

    Baked Lays Bbq
    Baked Lays Bbq

    SNACK A LITTLE SMARTER + Baked LAY’S BBQ Potato Chips. It’s the LAY’S BBQ chip you love; just Baked; so you still get 100% of that sweet/spicy BBQ flavor.

    Lays Bbq
    Lays Bbq

    It all starts + farm‐grown potatoes; cooked & seasoned to perfection. Then we add the spicy sweetness of BBQ sauce. So every LAYS potato chip is perfectly crispy & delicious. Happiness in Every Bite.

  • Sandwiches

    Italian B.m.t. Melt
    Italian B.m.t. Melt

    Three craveable meats; melty cheese & fresh veggies. It’s not too good to be true; it’s the Italian B.M.T. Melt. Now you can get the flavors you crave along + the goodness of fresh tomatoes; peppers & onions; that’s a win‐win.

    Meatball Marinara Melt
    Meatball Marinara Melt

    Add some melty goodness to your Meatball Marinara sub. Make it a Fresh Melt & get craveable meatballs & tangy marinara sauce topped + American & parmesan; all grilled to cheesy perfection. Freshly made in front of you.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.