Papa Johns Pizza - James City County

We ordered pizza Sunday for our daughter’s party, 3 came correct as did the order of garlic knots. However, the one pizza for the person paying was wrong it was missing extra items that cost extra, plus some extra spicy sauce cups on the side. When we called to have the issue corrected, we were offered a replacement pizza or a refund so we took the replacement. It NEVER showed up. What a joke, especially considering how ridiculous the price of pizza has become. I already hate ordering pizza but we did it because the girls were excited about it. But from now on we’ll stick with local places that value our business (Little Charlie’s and Bellissimo’s, plus they have great pizza).

I ordered extra toppings and barely got anything on my pizza felt like I should have just ordered a cheese pizza so I could have saved money I mean I didn't even ask for it on the whole pizza just half and if that's a whole pizza serving that is sad ??

The extra large shaq pepperoni was so good very hot still after delivery definitely will be ordering another

Good pizzas. Never know when I am in the area and in the mood for pizza so I walk in and order, don't mind the wait.

Pretty decent pizza, I ordered carry out through the app and my order was done within minutes!