Same Old Place. - Jamaica Plain

#31 - Pizza - Jamaica Plain, Italian, Steak And Cheese
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Same Old Place..

Same Old Place.

Same Old Place.
4.0 / 5 (4659 reviews)

Description

This pizza restaurant has received a mix of reviews from its customers. Some have had negative experiences with cold pizzas and rude staff, while others have enjoyed their meals and felt welcomed by the friendly Latino front staff. The lack of mushrooms on the mushroom pizza and unpleasant interactions with a particular employee have left some customers feeling dissatisfied, while others have praised the delicious pizzas and welcoming atmosphere of the restaurant. Despite varying experiences, the restaurant seems to have some loyal customers who appreciate the food and friendly service.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Sirena

Reservation request for Same Old Place.

Submit Reservation Request

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 4659 reviews
sirena-morena
22.08.2025

THE best pizza in the city. Great service. Can’t wait to try their desserts! Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

jose-diaz-beach75
22.08.2025

Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

haley-elvera
25.07.2022

For the first time from 12/1/18. the pizza of the rancher. chopped tomato, speck, chopped crispy chicken tsar and ranch dressing (and I added extra cheese) my brother ordered a large half cheese, half parfoni. $17.00 of mine was obviously a spicy. we were both fans. I saw and smells really good. also well tasted. my brother and I laughed because the small pizzabox was so much heavier than his big pizza, which also a heavy pizza box, but not as heavy as mine. remnant safe for me, so I have transformed it happy into two dinners. the pizza of the rancher from the same old place. oh, and we parked on Saturday night at 20:30 o'clock in front. that was comfortable/nice also in J.P!

ana-lia-gramajo
22.08.2025

Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4 Service: Takeaway Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $1–10 Recommended dishes: Chicken Finger Dinner

whalvorson
17.05.2022

I've been going to the same old place for over 30 years. during the pandemic, I continued to gunst the same old place by ordering for delivery but had some acidic experiences: cold pizzas when delivered; the wrong article delivered. I complained every time, and they solved the dinge, even another pizza to replace the cold one. even the replacement was not hot. unfortunately, my days are over as a satisfied customer. I had a humiliating experience tonight when I called myself to order a pizza. the author, macho, took my credit card number. I told him that the expiration date was 03/22, but he had key in 3/25. Therefore I gave him my credit card number a second time, and when he asked about the security code, I told him that it was 197 instead of 195. at this time he asked me to repeat all the numbers again what I was ready to do. but then he turned rudely and said that he would not command me. He has known me for years. he called me to an annoying because I have legally complained in the past. he hanged on me. I called back. he hanged up again. I called back a third time. he hung me up again. When I called for a fourth time, he told me he wouldn't take any orders from us. I just wanted to order a Hawaiian pizza, but because of macho's unrest, she developed into his insult.

FAQ

A little farther away is MBTA-Stony Brook, where you can also access the public transportation.

You can use the WiFi of the place at no extra cost.

There is a TV / screen on-site where sports events are broadcast.

The restaurant and its rooms are wheelchair accessible and thus reachable with a wheelchair or physiological limitations.

The place also accepts credit cards from the common providers as a means of payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.