Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.2 out of 5
Impressive | 3757 reviews

What Stephen V likes about Brooklyn Square Pizza:
Consistently excellent. If you have childhood memories of Spumoni Gardens, you won't be let down. Pete, the owner, is fantastic, and the staff is top-notch. I highly recommend this place. View all feedback. What Joette Giuliano doesn't like about Brooklyn Square Pizza:
The restaurant is overpriced. We paid $16 for one slice of pizza and a salad. We won't be returning. The service was for takeout and we had lunch. The price per person was in the $10-20 range. The food was rated a 3 out of 5. View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Restaurantji
4.4 ★ from 412 reviews
Dan
24.09.2024 - 13:39

Very , very good pizza atmosphere is casual and the service is great

M
24.09.2024 - 13:39

If you haven't had pizza from Brooklyn Square, then you haven't had pizza in your life!! This is true pizza, the crust, sauce, cheese everything is perfect. The...

read more
RL
24.09.2024 - 13:39

The only place for Italian food in south jersey.. Thank you Peter!!

Denise
24.09.2024 - 13:39

I don’t like making negative reviews but I don’t like being taking advantage of and this has happened to us previously but I just thought it was a busy Friday s...

read more
Jose
24.09.2024 - 13:39

Staff were all very friendly. I had a late lunch and was able to seat anywhere in the dining room. Parking: Decent size free lot for the plaza. Wheelchair acces...

read more
Menu
4.0 ★ from 14 reviews
Vince
18.07.2022 - 23:12

Huge fan! Been here twice since I tried it last week. Staff is friendly and the pizza is top tier.

Adrianna
18.07.2022 - 17:46

On holiday remained due to the Barstool review. the pizza is good! the sesame crust is great! they also have to get the original square disc! the owner was ther...

read more
Norwood
18.07.2022 - 17:46

I have to say this is one of the worst pizzeria restaurant in whole jackson. I come from new york I know quality eating and I had never chicken stable parmesan...

read more
Stephan
18.07.2022 - 17:46

This place is awesome. Their frozen pie is also very good. Wish there was one closer to me. Grandma pie is perfect and their NY slice can go up against some of...

read more
Lulu
18.07.2022 - 17:46

My cucumber and I just drove out of trenton to experience this highly valued square torte. we were not disappointed. the cake has a light radiance of the crust...

read more
Google
3.8 ★ from 7 reviews
edmond
11.11.2023 - 21:07

The restaurant offers very good food for dinner. The price per person ranges from $20 to $30. The service is rated a 3 out of 5, while the atmosphere also recei...

read more
Albert
11.11.2023 - 21:07

I had dinner at this restaurant and had a great experience. The price per person ranged from $10 to $20, which was very reasonable. The food was delicious, I wo...

read more
Joette
11.11.2023 - 21:07

The restaurant is overpriced. We paid $16 for one slice of pizza and a salad. We won't be returning. The service was for takeout and we had lunch. The price per...

read more
Albert
11.11.2023 - 21:07

Brooklyn square is the closest thing you'll have to eating brooklyn pizza if you know what that is. Staff is nice and friendly, food is good, great for pick up...

read more
Jerseyguy49
11.11.2023 - 21:07

Pizza was good and enough to make a take home box. Really not much atmosphere very old and tired decor. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10...

read more
Sirved
4.1 ★ from 299 reviews
Lulu
18.06.2023 - 07:00

I have to say this is one of the worst pizzeria restaurants in Jackson. I come from New York, I know quality food and I?ve never had chicken stable Parmesan tha...

read more
Jaylen
18.06.2023 - 07:00

Get the Upside Down Square. Even if you don't typically like Sicilian style. You wont regret it. Also, bring an extra person or two because there will be plenty...

read more
Myah
18.06.2023 - 07:00

Went for lunch May 2 2022 and bought a full pizza. Very expensive at $30. Pizza dough was premade, and doughy in the center. Also, Pizza was cold in the center...

read more
Maryjane
18.06.2023 - 07:00

So I hear Brooklyn Square has the best pizza in the state. And somehow after 15 years of marriage to a woman who's lived around the corner from it forever, I ne...

read more
Jayden
18.06.2023 - 07:00

I absolutely adore this place! The meatballs are perfectly cooked and fluffy, and the red sauce is excellent. If you're a fan of spicy food, definitely try the...

read more
Yelp
5.0 ★ from 3 reviews
Stephen
11.11.2023 - 21:07

Consistently excellent. If you have childhood memories of Spumoni Gardens, you won't be let down. Pete, the owner, is fantastic, and the staff is top-notch. I h...

read more
Jerry
11.11.2023 - 21:07

We finally made it to this place and we should have come sooner. The upside down square is amazing. The dining room was recently refurbished and the owner and s...

read more
David
11.11.2023 - 21:07

Peter is amazing! Make sure to try the upside down grandma pie. There is plenty of parking and the pizza is unbeatable.

Restaurantguru
4.3 ★ from 1858 reviews
Int Restaurants
4.5 ★ from 1164 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near Jackson

4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Toms River (near Jackson), 1177 Fischer Blvd, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA, United States
"Great Old School Italian food delivered in the new school era."
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Lakewood (near Jackson), 315 Cedar Bridge Ave, 08701, Lakewood, US, United States
"Very comfortable Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Point Pleasant (near Jackson), 2506 Bridge Ave, Point Pleasant, NJ, 08742, United States
"Always prepared to perfection! Always packaged well for travel!"
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Toms River (near Jackson), 65 Main St, 08753, Toms River, US, United States
"This is our 3rd trip for a bagel breakfast sandwich and it was as good as the first! Bagels are top notch quality and overstuffed . With meat, egg and..."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Point Pleasant Boro (near Jackson), 2621 Bridge Ave, 08742-4264, Point Pleasant Boro, United States
"Food was so good and the staff was very friendly."
4.7
Menu
Open Now
4.7
Menu
Open Now
City: Lakewood (near Jackson), 700 New Jersey 70, Lakewood, United States Of America
"Great little place to have a meal with family!"
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Point Pleasant (near Jackson), 3003 NJ-88, 08742, Point Pleasant, US, United States
"Best cream cheese and French toady bagels"
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Manalapan (near Jackson), 285 Gordons Corner Rd #7, 07726, Manalapan, US, United States
"Always good. healthy almost food."
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: SEA GIRT (near Jackson), 2150 NJ-35, 08750, Sea Girt, US, SEA GIRT, United States
"ALWAYS a great service, staff very pleasant!"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Manalapan (near Jackson), 300 Gordons Corner Rd, 07726, Manalapan, US, United States
"Food was good but delivery was delayed so came cold"