Old Mexico - Ithaca

#2 - Mexican - Ithaca, Cheese, Vegetarian
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via (+1)6073796178
Reservation
Reservation request for Old Mexico.

Menu

Here you will find the menu of Old Mexico in Ithaca. At the moment, there are 14 dishes and drinks on the menu.

Old Mexico is a must-visit gem near Midas, offering a perfect blend of flavor and service. The Tequila Shrimp Tacos stole the show – generous portions, delicious rice, and friendly staff. The massive vegetarian menu delighted a large group, who found every dish perfect. First-timers were blown away by the prompt service, incredible food, and welcoming ambiance. Despite minor delays, the food quality shone through, with standout margaritas and classic dishes. Even with some room for improvement in the details, Old Mexico's overall experience is excellent, earning praise for their authentic Mexican flavors and warm hospitality.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: User

Images

Old Mexico Outside

Reservation request for Old Mexico

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 10 reviews

Was User at Old Mexico a mag?
While waiting for my car to be serviced at the neighboring Midas, I tried the Tequila Shrimp Tacos at Old Mexico. I started with some delicious chips and salsa that really hit the spot. The tacos, served with rice and beans, were impressive – they were big, packed with shrimp, and more filling than I expected. I was tempted to save some for later, but ended up enjoying all three since I had extra time while waiting f... View all feedback.

kayden-22
Kayden 11.04.2021 - 13:41

Great beans and cheese! The salsa and guacamole are also great the food is classic Mexican restaurant food with great cocktails! But I was most impressed by the artwork inside!

While waiting for my car to be serviced at the neighboring Midas, I tried the Tequila Shrimp Tacos at Old Mexico. I started with some delicious chips and salsa that really hit the spot. The tacos, served with rice and beans, were impressive – they were big, packed with shrimp, and more filling than I expected. I was tempted to save some for later, but ended up enjoying all three since I had extra time while waiting for my car. The meal was very tasty, and I especially enjoyed the rice. The waiter was top-notch – professional and friendly. I highly recommend this restaurant!

maeve-41
Maeve 23.07.2017 - 14:36

Best Margarita I ever had! The food was also delicious. Great service.

The food was delicious and the portions were perfect. The margaritas were also good. A nice restaurant in Ithaca. Check if you visit the area.

We loved Old Mexico restaurant.. the 1400 plus reviews says it .. helpful staff made every effort to prepare menu items to our vegetarian choice.. We are so exited when food came.. I forgot to take pictures. BTW for 11 of us every dish came out perfect..

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.